Yellen’s Beijing visit fuels hopes of trade progress
Strong anti-China sentiment in the US could foil easing of Trump-era tariffs on Chinese imports
12 July 2023 - 12:45
by David Lawder and Andrea Shalal
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
US Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen. Picture: REUTERS
US Treasury secretary Janet Yellen’s trip to China has raised hopes in Beijing that Trump-era tariffs on Chinese imports may be eased as she tries to smooth relations between the two nations, but strong anti-China sentiment in the US may make that impossible.
Trade and political analysts in Washington say that even though cutting some of the “Section 301" tariffs would help US companies and consumers, as well as Chinese exporters, doing so would expose Biden to sharp Republican criticism at a dangerous time.
“The political calculus is pretty clear,” said Harry Broadman, a former White House, World Bank and US trade official who is now an MD with Berkeley Research Group. “That would be red meat for the opposition.”
Looking soft on China could cost Biden the 2024 presidential election, he added.
High hopes in China
Yellen discussed trade irritants and other policy differences with China’s top economic officials and Premier Li Qiang for 10 hours over two days last week — meetings that she said put US-China ties “on surer footing”.
US tariffs and controls on hi-tech exports in response to Beijing’s new anti-espionage law that threatens the activities of US firms in China were among the topics, the US Treasury said. Yellen said nothing publicly to indicate that the US was poised to ease tariffs, but commentators in China were hopeful, amid a US Trade Representative (USTR) review.
In a statement on Monday, China’s finance ministry called for the US to cancel punitive tariffs, roll back export curbs and end import bans from Xinjiang province.
“Yellen has a say in the next phase of the US’s four-year tariff review,” said Hong Hao, CEO of Grow Investment Group in Hong Kong. “While the US might continue its technological curbs on China, a reduction or exemption of noncore tariffs against China is possible.”
China’s state-run Global Times newspaper, normally a harsh US critic, called Yellen a “professional and pragmatic” official who could influence the Biden administration to take such steps to improve the economic relationship.
Yellen last year advocated eliminating some duties on “non-strategic” goods as a way to ease some specific costs amid high inflation.
But US political pressure to raise China tariffs is growing, said Chad Bown, a trade economist with the Peterson Institute of International Economics.
“There is no political appetite to reduce tariffs on China — Yellen will do well in this political climate if they manage to stay where they are,” Bown said.
US officials have been tight-lipped about any response to the Chinese call for action, noting that no new initiatives were under way. A Treasury spokesperson declined to comment on tariffs.
A USTR spokesperson said the agency was continuing its review and was evaluating feedback received, almost seven months after it closed public comments.
Collections of US tariffs on Chinese goods peaked at $49bn in fiscal 2022, bringing the total amount collected from US importers over four years to $182.9bn, according to US customs data.
US imports from China had almost reached their 2018 peak in 2022, but are down 24% so far this year.
‘Embarrassing grovelling’
Hardliners who dominate China discussions within the Republican party took to social media memes to mock Yellen for appearing to bow to Chinese vice-premier He Lifeng at the start of a meeting.
Firebrand Republican Senator Josh Hawley said in a tweet that such “embarrassing grovelling to China is a historic mistake”.
Republican presidential hopefuls have adopted confrontational rhetoric with respect to China, which they see as the nation’s top geopolitical foe.
Florida governor Ron DeSantis and former UN ambassador Nikki Haley have laid out the most specific plans so far to confront China on trade, and advocate revoking China’s permanent normal trade relations status, a legal designation granted by the US that lowers trade barriers with specific nations.
Haley has said she would push Congress to revoke China’s trade status until it curbs its alleged role in the fentanyl trade. China is a major producer of chemicals required to create fentanyl, which is frequently smuggled over the US-Mexico border.
Former president Donald Trump, who leads the Republican field with DeSantis a distant second, said he would give China 48 hours to remove what sources say is Chinese spy capability on the island of Cuba 145km miles off the US coast. His administration would impose new tariffs should China fail to comply.
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
Yellen’s Beijing visit fuels hopes of trade progress
Strong anti-China sentiment in the US could foil easing of Trump-era tariffs on Chinese imports
US Treasury secretary Janet Yellen’s trip to China has raised hopes in Beijing that Trump-era tariffs on Chinese imports may be eased as she tries to smooth relations between the two nations, but strong anti-China sentiment in the US may make that impossible.
Trade and political analysts in Washington say that even though cutting some of the “Section 301" tariffs would help US companies and consumers, as well as Chinese exporters, doing so would expose Biden to sharp Republican criticism at a dangerous time.
“The political calculus is pretty clear,” said Harry Broadman, a former White House, World Bank and US trade official who is now an MD with Berkeley Research Group. “That would be red meat for the opposition.”
Looking soft on China could cost Biden the 2024 presidential election, he added.
High hopes in China
Yellen discussed trade irritants and other policy differences with China’s top economic officials and Premier Li Qiang for 10 hours over two days last week — meetings that she said put US-China ties “on surer footing”.
US tariffs and controls on hi-tech exports in response to Beijing’s new anti-espionage law that threatens the activities of US firms in China were among the topics, the US Treasury said. Yellen said nothing publicly to indicate that the US was poised to ease tariffs, but commentators in China were hopeful, amid a US Trade Representative (USTR) review.
In a statement on Monday, China’s finance ministry called for the US to cancel punitive tariffs, roll back export curbs and end import bans from Xinjiang province.
“Yellen has a say in the next phase of the US’s four-year tariff review,” said Hong Hao, CEO of Grow Investment Group in Hong Kong. “While the US might continue its technological curbs on China, a reduction or exemption of noncore tariffs against China is possible.”
China’s state-run Global Times newspaper, normally a harsh US critic, called Yellen a “professional and pragmatic” official who could influence the Biden administration to take such steps to improve the economic relationship.
Yellen last year advocated eliminating some duties on “non-strategic” goods as a way to ease some specific costs amid high inflation.
But US political pressure to raise China tariffs is growing, said Chad Bown, a trade economist with the Peterson Institute of International Economics.
“There is no political appetite to reduce tariffs on China — Yellen will do well in this political climate if they manage to stay where they are,” Bown said.
US officials have been tight-lipped about any response to the Chinese call for action, noting that no new initiatives were under way. A Treasury spokesperson declined to comment on tariffs.
A USTR spokesperson said the agency was continuing its review and was evaluating feedback received, almost seven months after it closed public comments.
Collections of US tariffs on Chinese goods peaked at $49bn in fiscal 2022, bringing the total amount collected from US importers over four years to $182.9bn, according to US customs data.
US imports from China had almost reached their 2018 peak in 2022, but are down 24% so far this year.
‘Embarrassing grovelling’
Hardliners who dominate China discussions within the Republican party took to social media memes to mock Yellen for appearing to bow to Chinese vice-premier He Lifeng at the start of a meeting.
Firebrand Republican Senator Josh Hawley said in a tweet that such “embarrassing grovelling to China is a historic mistake”.
Republican presidential hopefuls have adopted confrontational rhetoric with respect to China, which they see as the nation’s top geopolitical foe.
Florida governor Ron DeSantis and former UN ambassador Nikki Haley have laid out the most specific plans so far to confront China on trade, and advocate revoking China’s permanent normal trade relations status, a legal designation granted by the US that lowers trade barriers with specific nations.
Haley has said she would push Congress to revoke China’s trade status until it curbs its alleged role in the fentanyl trade. China is a major producer of chemicals required to create fentanyl, which is frequently smuggled over the US-Mexico border.
Former president Donald Trump, who leads the Republican field with DeSantis a distant second, said he would give China 48 hours to remove what sources say is Chinese spy capability on the island of Cuba 145km miles off the US coast. His administration would impose new tariffs should China fail to comply.
Reuters
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.
Most Read
Published by Arena Holdings and distributed with the Financial Mail on the last Thursday of every month except December and January.