Despite owning assets such as Pepkor stakes, the company will remain insolvent as it is not valuable enough to fix its capital structure
30 March 2023 - 05:00
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
Shareholders in Steinhoff could not let creditors take over the crisis-hit company and benefit from the potential upside in its equity. That is the reason behind their vote last week to reject a debt reorganisation deal that would have meant CEO Louis du Preez’s five-year slog to revive the company is a step closer to paying off.
Broadly, Du Preez had hammered out a deal with creditors under which the latter would give Steinhoff a three-year breathing space from debt obligations in exchange for the 80% equity stake, and leave shareholders with 20% in the unlisted company that may be worth something later.
It is hard to see the wisdom in the vote. If anything, it has hastened Steinhoff’s reckoning with creditors, hedge funds who scooped up the company’s €10bn debt on the cheap in 2017 when risk-averse lenders fled.
Shareholders say that Du Preez should have done better in the negotiations with creditors. Steinhoff, they argue, has enough assets to leave something substantial on the table for equity investors, not the crumbs he agreed to. True, Steinhoff counts assets such as stakes in Pepkor but they are not valuable enough to fix the company’s lopsided capital structure. It would remain insolvent.
Steinhoff’s new plan to avert an asset fire sale is similar to the one rejected by shareholders last week except there’s nothing on the table for them. For creditors, a huge payday awaits but for shareholders there’s nothing but painfully won wisdom that a company built on a hodgepodge of assets requires an extremely long barge pole.
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
EDITORIAL: Steinhoff’s painful lesson
Despite owning assets such as Pepkor stakes, the company will remain insolvent as it is not valuable enough to fix its capital structure
Shareholders in Steinhoff could not let creditors take over the crisis-hit company and benefit from the potential upside in its equity. That is the reason behind their vote last week to reject a debt reorganisation deal that would have meant CEO Louis du Preez’s five-year slog to revive the company is a step closer to paying off.
Broadly, Du Preez had hammered out a deal with creditors under which the latter would give Steinhoff a three-year breathing space from debt obligations in exchange for the 80% equity stake, and leave shareholders with 20% in the unlisted company that may be worth something later.
It is hard to see the wisdom in the vote. If anything, it has hastened Steinhoff’s reckoning with creditors, hedge funds who scooped up the company’s €10bn debt on the cheap in 2017 when risk-averse lenders fled.
Shareholders say that Du Preez should have done better in the negotiations with creditors. Steinhoff, they argue, has enough assets to leave something substantial on the table for equity investors, not the crumbs he agreed to. True, Steinhoff counts assets such as stakes in Pepkor but they are not valuable enough to fix the company’s lopsided capital structure. It would remain insolvent.
Steinhoff’s new plan to avert an asset fire sale is similar to the one rejected by shareholders last week except there’s nothing on the table for them. For creditors, a huge payday awaits but for shareholders there’s nothing but painfully won wisdom that a company built on a hodgepodge of assets requires an extremely long barge pole.
EDITORIAL: A balanced outcome for the public sector
EDITORIAL: Call it what it is, Minister Ramokgopa
EDITORIAL: Why did South Africans stay home?
EDITORIAL: Rising cost of living requires staying the course on rate hikes
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.
Most Read
Related Articles
Steinhoff comes up with new debt plan — shareholders lose everything
Steinhoff share price plummets as shareholders set to lose all
‘Give them hell’: Steinhoff shareholders reject debt restructuring deal
Published by Arena Holdings and distributed with the Financial Mail on the last Thursday of every month except December and January.