The argument that the franchise system is where SA’s problems start is not as sound as its proponents would like us to believe
29 October 2019 - 15:16
byTelford Vice
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
SA cricket’s domestic competitions are in as sharp a focus as the national team in the wake of the latter’s disastrous Test series in India.
And the former are ahead on the bigger picture’s scoreboard in the current round of franchise first-class matches.
Only six of the dozen fit players who shambled to a 3-0 loss in India are playing for their franchises and none of them made an impact on the first day’s play on Monday‚ though only four had the opportunity.
That asks questions of the prevailing view that the quality chasm between domestic and international cricket is an important reason why SA were so disappointing against Virat Kohli’s team.
Heinrich Klaasen and Zubayr Hamza did not bat for the Titans and the Cobras on Monday and in Tuesday’s first session in their games against the Knights and the Warriors, respectively.
But Senuran Muthusamy did for the Dolphins against the Lions and managed only 23 off 58 balls in almost two hours before he skied a pull to midwicket.
Lungi Ngidi bowled 13 overs for the Titans and took 1/59‚ Dane Piedt had a similar day at the office for the Cobras, claiming 1/57 off 23, and teammate George Linde went wicketless in nine overs that yielded 22 runs.
None of those performances were particularly poor‚ but they also did not illustrate why the standard in the domestic arena is so far below what it needs to be for SA to perform better at international level.
Piedt took another wicket in the morning session on Tuesday‚ and Linde went to lunch with figures of 3/67, but Ngidi found no more success in the five overs he bowled‚ in which he went for 25 runs. Muthusamy bowled only one over before lunch and conceded three runs.
While all that was not happening‚ Raynard van Tonder‚ the Knights’ 21-year-old opening batter‚ was scoring 204, and five other allegedly lesser lights banked scores of between 61 and 70.
No doubt SA players are readjusting to their home conditions after weeks on the subcontinent‚ and perhaps they are still recovering from the physical and mental aspects of the beating they took there.
But the argument that the franchise system is where SA’s problems start is not as sound as its proponents would like us to believe.
Could it be the other way around: because SA’s players consider themselves so superior to what is seen week in‚ week out on the country’s major grounds they do not pay the domestic game the required respect?
And that‚ consequently‚ they are being exposed as arrogant and complacent when they can least afford it?
That is too neat an explanation‚ but it deserves to be part of the conversation that cricket in SA must have with itself if it is to improve.
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
Proteas stars struggle to make first-class impact
The argument that the franchise system is where SA’s problems start is not as sound as its proponents would like us to believe
SA cricket’s domestic competitions are in as sharp a focus as the national team in the wake of the latter’s disastrous Test series in India.
And the former are ahead on the bigger picture’s scoreboard in the current round of franchise first-class matches.
Only six of the dozen fit players who shambled to a 3-0 loss in India are playing for their franchises and none of them made an impact on the first day’s play on Monday‚ though only four had the opportunity.
That asks questions of the prevailing view that the quality chasm between domestic and international cricket is an important reason why SA were so disappointing against Virat Kohli’s team.
Heinrich Klaasen and Zubayr Hamza did not bat for the Titans and the Cobras on Monday and in Tuesday’s first session in their games against the Knights and the Warriors, respectively.
But Senuran Muthusamy did for the Dolphins against the Lions and managed only 23 off 58 balls in almost two hours before he skied a pull to midwicket.
Lungi Ngidi bowled 13 overs for the Titans and took 1/59‚ Dane Piedt had a similar day at the office for the Cobras, claiming 1/57 off 23, and teammate George Linde went wicketless in nine overs that yielded 22 runs.
None of those performances were particularly poor‚ but they also did not illustrate why the standard in the domestic arena is so far below what it needs to be for SA to perform better at international level.
Piedt took another wicket in the morning session on Tuesday‚ and Linde went to lunch with figures of 3/67, but Ngidi found no more success in the five overs he bowled‚ in which he went for 25 runs. Muthusamy bowled only one over before lunch and conceded three runs.
While all that was not happening‚ Raynard van Tonder‚ the Knights’ 21-year-old opening batter‚ was scoring 204, and five other allegedly lesser lights banked scores of between 61 and 70.
No doubt SA players are readjusting to their home conditions after weeks on the subcontinent‚ and perhaps they are still recovering from the physical and mental aspects of the beating they took there.
But the argument that the franchise system is where SA’s problems start is not as sound as its proponents would like us to believe.
Could it be the other way around: because SA’s players consider themselves so superior to what is seen week in‚ week out on the country’s major grounds they do not pay the domestic game the required respect?
And that‚ consequently‚ they are being exposed as arrogant and complacent when they can least afford it?
That is too neat an explanation‚ but it deserves to be part of the conversation that cricket in SA must have with itself if it is to improve.
NEIL MANTHORP: Seeds from Papua New Guinea and the Big Bash
Only six India Test series survivors turn out for franchises
David Warner belts out birthday T20 ton as Australia slam Sri Lanka
More trouble for Cricket SA as players declare dispute
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.
Most Read
Related Articles
Ruthless India complete SA’s humiliation
NEIL MANTHORP: Cricket SA’s poor leadership now reflecting in Proteas ...
Faf is finding out what happens when a good captain’s team doesn’t shape up
SA face worst day in 83 years as 16 wickets crash in Ranchi
Published by Arena Holdings and distributed with the Financial Mail on the last Thursday of every month except December and January.