Cyril Ramaphosa tears into DA’s ‘disingenuous’ election monitoring letter
President accuses party of ‘trying to mortgage our country’ after it asked Western countries to ‘ensure the integrity’ of the election
12 March 2024 - 12:57
bySINESIPHO SCHRIEBER
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
President Cyril Ramaphosa had no kind words for the DA as he criticised the party for writing to Western countries asking for them to monitor and “ensure the integrity” of the upcoming national and provincial elections, despite SA having had independent observers during previous polls.
DA shadow minister of international relations Emma Powell wrote to US secretary of state Antony Blinken and 13 other foreign ministers last week, asking the foreign governments to deploy election observers to SA.
Ramaphosa described the DA’s move as “disingenuous and almost trying to mortgage our country to other powers in the world”. He said SA elections had been successfully monitored for years by representatives from the UN and the Southern African Development Community (Sadc) and no “rigged votes” were flagged by observers.
“We have our regional organisations, we have Sadc and indeed we have representatives of the UN as well. They always come to monitor our elections and we invite them to monitor. For a non-state entity [DA] to do something like that is basically saying we are mortgaging our democracy,” Ramaphosa said.
In the letter, Powell accused the ANC of clinging to power and former president Jacob Zuma’s Umkhonto weSizwe (MK) party as posing a risk to a peaceful election.
“Here, we are witnessing an increasing willingness by the ANC to forge alliances with malign international actors whose regimes are characterised by tyranny, terror and oppression.
“We therefore appeal to your government to recognise the high stakes for SA in the lead up to and aftermath of the NPE2024 [national and provincial election 2024]. It is in this context that we now formally request our partners in democracy to engage with consequence in the run-up to the election,” Powell’s letter read.
International relations and co-operation minister Naledi Pandor agreed with Ramaphosa.
“SA has had six elections which have always been declared free and fair. We always had election observations which have [included] over 120 from different countries and organisations. To write such a letter, particularly to countries that do not have observations and have low participation rates in the elections, is rather surprising and demeaning,” Pandor said.
IEC CEO Sy Mamabolo said the commission was not against election observers, but the DA had tackled the issue in an unusual manner.
“The commission believes that elections must be observed because observation gives us credibility. Nonetheless, we are alive to the fact that the letter by the DA is directly to an executive in another country. That is not how ordinarily the observation process works. Often the observation works at a multilateral level, AU, Sadc and so on,” Mamabolo said.
“In the past, invitations have been extended to those multilateral bodies to come and observe the elections. So I think all the role players need to be alive to the fact that the issues need to preserve the integrity of democratic processes in respective countries.”
The IEC does allow international and domestic organisations to apply to monitor election as observers.
There were various reactions to the DA letter on social media, including the following:
Notes on “How to lose an election”This feigned ‘concern’ over South Africa’s electoral processes - which have largely been free & fair for almost 3 DECADES- is disingenuous at best. Asking America for “help” is laughable & dangerous for the reasons Redi has laid out in her thread https://t.co/cMXnXpwHJK
The IEC says it doesn't mind international observers during May 29 elections. However, CEO Sy Mamabolo, says this has to be done through appropriate multi-lateral institutions. This is after the DA wrote a letter to the US requesting assistance in upcoming polls.… pic.twitter.com/PKc2iF82ND
I am in awe reading a letter written by the DA asking the American government to interfere in South African affairs, to assist them to ensure that ANC and MK do not… pic.twitter.com/r0oQcLu911
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
Cyril Ramaphosa tears into DA’s ‘disingenuous’ election monitoring letter
President accuses party of ‘trying to mortgage our country’ after it asked Western countries to ‘ensure the integrity’ of the election
President Cyril Ramaphosa had no kind words for the DA as he criticised the party for writing to Western countries asking for them to monitor and “ensure the integrity” of the upcoming national and provincial elections, despite SA having had independent observers during previous polls.
DA shadow minister of international relations Emma Powell wrote to US secretary of state Antony Blinken and 13 other foreign ministers last week, asking the foreign governments to deploy election observers to SA.
Ramaphosa described the DA’s move as “disingenuous and almost trying to mortgage our country to other powers in the world”. He said SA elections had been successfully monitored for years by representatives from the UN and the Southern African Development Community (Sadc) and no “rigged votes” were flagged by observers.
“We have our regional organisations, we have Sadc and indeed we have representatives of the UN as well. They always come to monitor our elections and we invite them to monitor. For a non-state entity [DA] to do something like that is basically saying we are mortgaging our democracy,” Ramaphosa said.
In the letter, Powell accused the ANC of clinging to power and former president Jacob Zuma’s Umkhonto weSizwe (MK) party as posing a risk to a peaceful election.
“Here, we are witnessing an increasing willingness by the ANC to forge alliances with malign international actors whose regimes are characterised by tyranny, terror and oppression.
“We therefore appeal to your government to recognise the high stakes for SA in the lead up to and aftermath of the NPE2024 [national and provincial election 2024]. It is in this context that we now formally request our partners in democracy to engage with consequence in the run-up to the election,” Powell’s letter read.
International relations and co-operation minister Naledi Pandor agreed with Ramaphosa.
“SA has had six elections which have always been declared free and fair. We always had election observations which have [included] over 120 from different countries and organisations. To write such a letter, particularly to countries that do not have observations and have low participation rates in the elections, is rather surprising and demeaning,” Pandor said.
IEC CEO Sy Mamabolo said the commission was not against election observers, but the DA had tackled the issue in an unusual manner.
“The commission believes that elections must be observed because observation gives us credibility. Nonetheless, we are alive to the fact that the letter by the DA is directly to an executive in another country. That is not how ordinarily the observation process works. Often the observation works at a multilateral level, AU, Sadc and so on,” Mamabolo said.
“In the past, invitations have been extended to those multilateral bodies to come and observe the elections. So I think all the role players need to be alive to the fact that the issues need to preserve the integrity of democratic processes in respective countries.”
The IEC does allow international and domestic organisations to apply to monitor election as observers.
There were various reactions to the DA letter on social media, including the following:
TOM EATON: The cabal of cabbages has the skill to steal an election — really?
EDITORIAL: Leaked election lists not a good start
YACOOB ABBA OMAR: Mayihlome! Let the election drum beat on
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.
Most Read
Related Articles
Aaron Motsoaledi defends political party funding proposals
ANC faces historic defeat in general election, according to surveys
PRANISH DESAI: Why political accountability matters for a fair electoral system
Published by Arena Holdings and distributed with the Financial Mail on the last Thursday of every month except December and January.