Merck shuts down vaccine trial after ‘disappointing’ results
The failure of its more traditional strategy to produce results will leave the drug giant locked out of a race likely to be dominated by its US rivals
New York — Merck & Co is discontinuing development of its two experimental Covid-19 vaccines after early trial data showed they failed to generate immune responses comparable to a natural infection or existing vaccines.
The US drug giant, which has a long history of successfully developing vaccines, had adopted a different strategy from rivals Pfizer, Moderna and Johnson & Johnson, using a more traditional approach of focusing on shots based on weakened viruses. One, called V590, borrowed technology from Merck’s Ebola inoculation, while the other, V591, is based on a measles vaccine used in Europe.
Both V590 and V591 were laggards in the vaccine development race. Merck finished recruiting the first participants for early-stage safety studies near the end of 2020, when front-runners Pfizer and Moderna were preparing to report late-stage data on their shots’ effectiveness. Merck received interim results from its trials this month.
The results were “disappointing, and a bit of a surprise”, said Nick Kartsonis, senior vice-president of clinical research for infectious diseases & vaccines at Merck Research Laboratories. Both shots generated fewer neutralising antibodies to halt infection than other Covid-19 vaccines, and produced inferior immune responses compared with people who had naturally contracted the coronavirus.
“We didn’t have what we needed to be able to move forward,” Kartsonis said in an interview on Sunday. After evaluating the data, Merck’s senior leadership decided to discontinue the programmes and divert resources to the company’s efforts to develop Covid-19 treatments.
The shares fell 0.8% in trading before US markets opened on Monday. They’ve lost 9.7% over the past 12 months through Friday’s close.
While Merck’s vaccines weren’t expected to be part of the initial immunisation push in the US, the development comes amid heightened anxiety over vaccine supplies and a sluggish pace of injections. The emergence of new variants of the coronavirus has also raised questions about whether the shots that have been cleared will lose effectiveness as the pathogen mutates.
The failure of Merck’s candidates will also leave it locked out of a market that could eventually be dominated by two of its historic US rivals. Pfizer was the first drugmaker to gain authorisation for a Covid vaccine in the US, followed closely by Moderna, and in coming weeks, Johnson & Johnson is expected to publish data on its vaccine’s efficacy and apply for an emergency-use authorisation.
Neither of Merck’s candidates were ultimately among the six primary vaccines in the US government’s Operation Warp Speed portfolio, though its leadership watched them closely. The drugmaker and its partner, the International AIDS Vaccine Initiative (IAVI), did receive some research funding from the government. Both candidates would have been single-dose shots.
Kenilworth, New Jersey-based Merck will record a pretax charge for the fourth quarter of 2020 for costs related to halting the programmes. It didn’t disclose the amount of the charge on Monday. The early-stage trial results will be submitted to a peer-reviewed medical journal.
Two coronavirus vaccines have been cleared for use in the US, but a continuing surge in infections has highlighted the need for more treatment options. Merck will steer resources towards two drugs it has in late-stage development to combat the disease, according to Kartsonis.
“In the world of pharmaceutical development, a quick kill is not a bad thing because it allows you to reposition and repurpose your assets,” he said.
Several of Merck’s vaccine manufacturing facilities are being retooled to produce one of its Covid-19 drug candidates, MK-7110, which is complex and difficult to manufacture at mass scale. In an interim study, the intravenous therapy significantly improved the likelihood and speed of recovery for severe and critical Covid-19 patients needing oxygen, reducing the risks of respiratory failure and death by more than 50%. Full study results are expected in the first quarter.
Merck’s executives expect US regulators will grant an emergency-use authorisation for the drug following those results, and Kartsonis said it could reach sick patients by the middle of the year. The US has already agreed to pay $365 million for 60,000 to 100,000 doses.
Merck is also working on a pill for Covid-19 patients at earlier stages of the disease. Known as molnupiravir, the antiviral therapy was discovered by scientists at Emory University and is being studied in late-stage trials in both hospital and outpatient settings. Merck and partner Ridgeback Biotherapeutics LP expect to have initial data on the drug’s effectiveness in the first quarter, and to wrap up studies in May, the company said in a statement.
Chief Marketing Officer Michael Nally said in December that Merck expects a regulatory clearance shortly after the company reports data, should it prove successful.
Read More: Single Rolodex Helps Operation Warp Speed Live Up to Its Name
The antiviral is intended to be taken twice a day over five days, for a total of ten capsules. Merck anticipates it will be able to produce more than 20 million courses of the treatment, or 200 million capsules, in 2021, Nally said.
The slow vaccine rollout shows that a need for therapeutics will persist, Kartsonis said, and the drugs could work against future viruses.
Would you like to comment on this article or view other readers' comments?
Register (it’s quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.