Israeli mining tycoon and Guinea make peace — and seal a new deal
Settlement ends a seven-year dispute over a lucrative iron-ore project
Israeli mining tycoon Beny Steinmetz is making a dramatic return to Guinea after the billionaire ended a bitter dispute with the West African country that brought his business empire to its knees.
The settlement, brokered by former French president Nicolas Sarkozy, ends a seven-year dispute centred on one of the world’s richest mineral deposits that included a colourful list of characters from billionaire George Soros to former UK leader Tony Blair and mining heavyweights Rio Tinto Group and Vale SA.
After months of secret negotiations, Steinmetz’s BSG Resources agreed with Guinean President Alpha Conde to withdraw allegations of corruption levelled against each other over years and to drop a two-year-old arbitration case over one of the world’s most-fabled mineral deposits — the Simandou iron ore project. Guinea also agreed to partner with mining grandee Mick Davis, who will develop the Zogota iron-ore mine once the disputes have been settled, marking a comeback for one of the industry’s biggest names.
The reconciliation puts Steinmetz, BSGR and Davis in prime position to lead the development of Guinea’s massive iron-ore reserves. Mining giants such as Rio Tinto, Vale and Aluminum Corp of China have all failed to develop projects in the country.
“A good agreement is much better than any war,” Steinmetz, who acts as an adviser to BSGR, said on Sunday. “We were enemies. Now we are friends and partners with the Guinean government. We have both put aside the past and BSGR and its employees and advisers have been vindicated.”
For Steinmetz, the heir to one of Israel’s premier diamond businesses, the arrangement is a remarkable return to favour in Guinea. BSGR entered administration a year ago to protect itself from the outcome of litigation and arbitration it was involved in related to the country.
In 2012 Guinea stripped BSGR of its rights to Zogota and half of Simandou, thought by miners to be the world’s biggest undeveloped iron-ore deposit. A government committee alleged he and his officials paid millions in bribes to obtain the rights.
“We are all really pleased with the situation,” Steinmetz said. “Guinea wants to work and they see us as the pioneers of the iron-ore situation, because nobody else has picked it up. Production and export of iron ore will be expedited and this is a win-win situation for everyone.”
Sarkozy, who was in office between 2007 and 2012, had a relationship with both sides and was able to broker the deal, according to a person with knowledge of his role.
Long-time director Dag Cramer negotiated the deal for BSGR, a firm owned by a Steinmetz family foundation. Under its terms, the company relinquishes rights to Simandou and Zogota and Davis will develop the smaller deposit.
BSGR keeps an economic interest in Zogota, which, according to Steinmetz, will move towards production “very fast”. The company will get a share of the revenue from the new project, which will be developed by Davis in partnership with Guinea.
“We’re pleased with the agreement,” Guinea’s mines minister Abdoulaye Magassouba said in a statement, adding that the new projects will be in line with the country’s new mining code. “It’s for the good of the people. It’s with this aim that the government will try hard to work in a win-win partnership with the investors.”
The reconciliation suits both sides. Guinea faced the possibility of an embarrassing loss in arbitration court, while BSGR would have been able to do little with an award by the tribunal if Guinea’s government remained hostile. The government withdrew all allegations of corruption against BSGR and Steinmetz.
Steinmetz, 62, was originally sent out by his family to secure supplies of rough diamonds, introducing him to difficult environments across the globe. He developed a diamond mine in Sierra Leone before setting his sights on Simandou in neighbouring Guinea.
Ailing president Lansana Conte stripped Rio Tinto of its rights to half of the asset, which the Anglo-Australian miner had not developed in a decade of control. The rights lost by Rio were transferred to Steinmetz weeks before the president died in 2008.
BSGR rapidly sold half of its Guinean assets to iron-ore mining giant Vale SA for $2.5bn.
After Conde was elected in 2010 he announced a review and clean-up of the mining industry, Guinea’s main source of income. Billionaire hedge fund manager George Soros and former UK prime minister Tony Blair advised on and funded Conde’s initiative. A lurid dossier of alleged corruption against Steinmetz became the basis for BSGR’s loss of rights in 2012.
Steinmetz and BSGR always denied any wrongdoing and insisted they would one day be vindicated. Rio Tinto, meanwhile, is now under investigation in the UK and Australia for payments it made to a consultant to try to restore its rights to Simandou.
The Guinean saga has been more than just a painful business loss for Steinmetz. He has been the subject of investigations by authorities in the US, Switzerland, Romania and Israel, where he was briefly detained in 2016 and then placed under house arrest.
Though Simandou has long been a fabled asset, developing it may be impossible. It would require an investment of $20bn, including the construction of railway lines across a mountainous country. Rio attempted to later sell its share of the project to Aluminum Corp of China, but the deal collapsed in 2018.
Davis may have a favourable solution, with the government allowing him to export via an existing railway line through neighbouring Liberia, using his newly formed Niron Metals venture.
“Niron believes that the Zogota deposit can be brought into production on an accelerated timetable, thereby helping to unlock the potential of Guinea’s rich resources for the benefit of all stakeholders, including the government and people of Guinea,” the company said in a statement.
Davis, nicknamed Mick the Miner, was one of the industry’s most successful operators in the early part of the decade as the mining industry boomed on China’s rampant industrialisation. As Xstrata CEO, Davis led a team renowned for transforming the coal producer through about 40 deals worth $35bn over 10 years from 2002, before agreeing to a friendly merger with commodity trader Glencore, where Ivan Glasenberg managed to beat him to the top job.
Since then, the Conservative Party treasurer has struggled to regain a footing. His private equity vehicle X2 Resources folded after failing to make any deals amid volatile commodity prices and disparate investors who could not agree on what assets to buy.