‘I did nothing deliberately wrong,’ says Steinhoff’s Ben la Grange
"I do not think I did anything deliberately wrong," former Steinhoff CFO Ben la Grange insisted in parliament on Wednesday.
La Grange, who was CFO from 2013 until his suspension earlier this year, appeared for the first time before a phalanx of members from four parliamentary committees — finance, public accounts, trade and industry, and public service and administration — to explain his thoughts on what went wrong at the global retailing group.
He said he was "deeply saddened by the events at Steinhoff and all the money that was lost." He also told MPs "there was a limited sharing of information from [former Steinhoff CEO] Markus Jooste."
La Grange said he believed one of the things that would have decreased the risk of what happened at Steinhoff was if the group had had a single set of auditors that was able to identify the nature of transactions at different levels of the group, and which would have been able to pick up misstatements.
There were many layers of companies in the enormous group with multiple levels of reporting and scrutiny. Each level had its own board with its own internal audit committee and auditors that would report upwards and consolidate at each higher layer until the top layer — where all the reports were consolidated into the holding company’s group financial statements. La Grange was mainly responsible for Africa and co-responsible for the US operations.
At holding group level, the financial statements flowing upwards were never re-audited, though trends were analysed to pick up irregularities in the movement of large balances.
La Grange identified three areas of accounting irregularities in Steinhoff International Holdings: inflated profits; the acquisition of assets at inflated values; and transactions that were apparently with third parties but which were influenced by Jooste.
The main source of inflated profits came from contributions from a fictitious external buying company. La Grange said he had been led to believe there was an external buying group that paid rebates to operating companies, but it turned out that it did not exist and was funded by loans from Steinhoff. Payments from the buying group were reflected as income in the Steinhoff books. The bulk of this activity took place in Europe.
La Grange said he was suspended because of the issuance of an invoice from the African group of companies that he authorised to the buying group.