Kering share falls after announcing plan to give up control of Puma
Paris/Berlin — Gucci parent Kering is returning its ill-fitting Pumas.
The French company’s plan to give up control of Puma, focusing solely on luxury and catwalk brands like Stella McCartney and Saint Laurent, sent the German sportswear outfitter plummeting 16% in early Frankfurt trading. The fall was its worst since September 2001.
The plan, under which Kering will distribute to its investors 70% of the shares of Puma, will leave Kering founder Francois Pinault’s holding company Artemis with about 29% of Puma. Kering fell as much as 2.3% in Paris after earlier rising as much as 1.6%.
Kering’s decision disappointed some Puma investors who had hoped that the French company would find a buyer willing to pay a premium for the shares.
"This exit scenario is not the best one for Puma’s minority shareholders," Cedric Lecasble, an analyst at Raymond James in Paris, wrote in a report. "A straightforward disposal of Puma at a premium might have been partly priced in by the market."
Also, Kering shareholders may decide to sell the Puma shares they receive in the spinoff, pressuring the stock in the short term, he said.
Kering follows rivals in cleaning up its portfolio after LVMH sold Donna Karan and Hermes International divested Leica. The decision to spin off Puma is evidence of a lack of acquisition opportunities in luxury goods in the near term, Lecasble said.
Kering bought Puma in 2007 as part of a push into sport and lifestyle brands that also saw the group acquire skateboarding brand Volcom. Puma was seen at the time as a pioneer for its fusion of fashion and performance clothing and its collaborations with designers from Philippe Starck to Alexander McQueen.
Puma’s shares have underperformed Germany’s CDAX Index since Kering bought the stake for €330 a share. The stock has returned 5.7% including dividends, compared with 89% for the benchmark. In the same period, Nike returned 454% and Adidas returned 360%.
"The contemplated distribution of Puma shares to our shareholders would be a significant milestone in the history of the group," Kering chairperson Francois-Henri Pinault, the son of Francois Pinault, said in the statement. "Kering would dedicate itself entirely to the development of its luxury houses."
Puma accounted for about 30% of Kering’s sales in 2016.
Under Kering’s ownership, initiatives like the higher-priced Fenty Puma by Rihanna collection have helped the apparel maker boost brand image and profitability after a period when low desirability and an overextended store network had made for an unpopular match with investors. But Kering struggled to integrate it firmly into its stable of other brands, and the company has promised shareholders it would work toward becoming a pure player in luxury.
Terms of the share distribution are under review and will be submitted to Kering shareholders for a vote on April 26, the company said. Luca Solca, an analyst at Exane BNP Paribas, said he estimated the ratio should be about one Puma share for each 12 of Kering.
Sophie Park, an analyst at Bank of America Merrill Lynch, cut Puma shares to underperform from buy, saying the stock did not deserve a valuation premium to Adidas given that the companies were growing at about the same rate. The company also may be pressured by price-cutting in the European market, she wrote.
The Pinaults have gradually pushed Kering’s portfolio upmarket since the company took a controlling stake in Gucci in 2001. The family, which also owns the auction house Christie’s, sold its 24.3% stake in the French books-and-electronics group Darty in July 2017.
Kering will sell its remaining lifestyle holding, Volcom, "when the time is right" and a solution is found that is good for both Kering and the brand, chief financial officer Jean-Marc Duplaix said in a call with reporters.
"This was a simple, rapid way of creating value for our investors or giving them the option to sell," he said of the transaction.
Puma is based in the German provincial town of Herzogenaurach, the same city as Adidas. The two companies were founded by brothers, and both had an early core foothold in soccer. Adidas is by far the bigger of the two by sales and market value, while Puma has sought to burnish its credentials in street fashion and collaborations with music superstars like Rihanna.
"We’re very pleased Kering has proposed this way to reduce its stake in Puma, as it allows us to continue with our current business strategy," Puma CEO Björn Gulden said on a conference call with reporters, adding there would be no changes to the company’s strategy due to the change of ownership. "Kering and Artemis will remain strong partners and shareholders, which proves they believe in our strategy."
Kering will retain about 16% of Puma’s outstanding shares and said it will remain a long-term shareholder, despite speculation it could exit entirely.
"The eventual sale of the remaining stake in Puma will give Kering additional resources to finance possible acquisitions or to accelerate their debt repayment," wrote Mario Ortelli, an analyst at Sanford C Bernstein.