Precious Angels owner admits she should not have taken in 58 psychiatric patients
Ethel Ncube was giving testimony at arbitration hearings about the more than 118 Gauteng health department psychiatric patients who died between June 2016 and February
Ethel Ncube‚ owner of the Precious Angels nongovernmental organisation (NGO) in which 23 mentally ill adults died‚ has finally admitted that she should not have taken 58 adults into her care.
She has been giving testimony in the Life Esidimeni arbitration hearings‚ held to give closure to families‚ so they can learn why their loved ones died.
Of the more than 118 psychiatric patients who died between June 2016 and February‚ the highest number of people died at Precious Angels.
Advocate Nontlantla Yina asked her: "Do you think you should have taken these patients?"
Ncube answered: "No. My capacity is children."
Ncube runs a daycare facility for disabled and intellectually impaired children‚ as she has a disabled child. She testified that she has no qualification in caring for adults or sick people. She started studying accounting but did not finish‚ and has received a certificate in early childhood education.
Yet the Gauteng department of health placed 58 elderly‚ frail and mentally ill people in her care.
The health ombud, Malegapuru Makgoba‚ found that patients died from a lack of care due to inexperienced staff‚ a lack of food and from the cold.
Ncube said the Gauteng department of health did not give her money for three months.
"We did not get paid for three months. Most of the patients were on diapers. We would [use] seven bags of diapers in a day or two."
She said she relied on donations from family‚ and used savings from her stokvel groups as well as her mother’s savings to feed patients.
She did not pay rent and was evicted. "I suffered‚" she said‚ also disclosing that her car was repossessed.
Inexplicably‚ Ncube later took in more psychiatric patients‚ until she had 58 staying in two residential homes. She told the court: "[Gauteng department officials and director Dr Makgabo Manamela] asked if we could assist for a period of time. We refused; [the department of health] kept on insisting."
Eventually‚ she was paid R100‚000 a month‚ and paid caregivers R1‚700.
Ncube testified that in some cases they were short of staff and had to cook in one home‚ then transport food to another about 15 minutes away.
Lawyers read out claims that patients had to take turns eating because of a shortage of spoons‚ which Ncube said was "incorrect".
Adults were put in two homes‚ one in Danville and another in Atteridgeville‚ while she also ran a daycare facility for disabled children in Atteridgeville.
Yina pointed out that Ncube may have had too much to do: "Between running three centres and having meetings with the department‚ were you are able to oversee patients?"
When Judge Dikgang Moseneke asked her if it was true that 23 people died in her care from cold and hunger‚ she said that she "objected".
Moseneke reiterated: "In six months‚ 23 people under your care died, and you say they died of natural causes?"
Ncube replied: "We wouldn’t know — I would also like to get closure and get peace."
Moseneke pressed her: "I don’t understand what you are saying killed 23 people under your care."
Ncube eventually asserted: "It happened from frustration [of the patients] being moved from pillar to post."
Family members sighed and muttered as she failed to answer questions‚ but gave lengthy responses. Moseneke had to tell her multiple times to be brief‚ and eventually exclaimed: "You are being too guarded — just answer the question. I am not judging you. I just want the facts."
The court heard that conditions at Precious Angels were very overcrowded — 37 members were placed in one house with eight rooms‚ with large rooms taking seven people.
Section 27 advocate Adila Hassim read out testimony, saying: "Overcrowding meant people were confined to bed‚ when they could have benefited from interacting with patients in gardens".
Ncube denied this.