Chip industry makes pitch for $50bn to keep manufacturing in US
China’s government is pouring money into its domestic semiconductor industry, says lobby group
San Francisco — The US chip industry said it needs as much as $50bn in federal incentives to halt a decades-long trend of manufacturing moving overseas as China spends heavily to become a leading semiconductor producer.
The federal government needs to deploy $20bn to $50bn to make the US as attractive a location for plants as Taiwan, China, South Korea, Singapore, Israel and parts of Europe, the Semiconductor Industry Association (SIA) said in a study released Wednesday. Failure to do that threatens US leadership of the sector as a whole, it added.
The lobby group, which represents companies such as Intel and Qualcomm, is making the pitch at a time when it believes Washington is more open to listening. The China-U. S. trade war and supply-chain disruptions caused by the pandemic have revealed the risks of having such vital components made abroad.
“Six months ago, I don’t think we could have had this discussion, the world’s gone in our direction,” said John Neuffer, CEO of the SIA. “It’s not a bit of a change in Washington, it’s a significant shift.”
The $400bn semiconductor industry is led by US companies, but many chipmakers, such as Nvidia and Qualcomm, outsource production to factories mostly in Asia. Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing dominates that part of the market and also makes chips designed by Apple and other US tech giants.
Production techniques, including chemical processes, and complex manufacturing equipment play a vital role in determining chip performance. The US needs to keep a chunk of this work domestic so it can maintain its knowledge base and ownership of the skills, the SIA said.
While US production ebbs, China’s government is pouring money into its domestic semiconductor industry, conferring the same kind of priority on the effort it accorded to building its atomic capability. That has made chip manufacturing a matter of national security.
The SIA said new US plants built with federal support “would bring state-of-the-art manufacturing technology and sufficient capacity to cover semiconductor demand from the US defence and aerospace industries”.
Only 6% of the new global capacity in development will be located in the US. In contrast, China will add about 40% of the new capacity over the next decade and become the largest semiconductor manufacturing location in the world, the SIA noted in its report.
Senator John Cornyn is sponsoring a bipartisan Chips for America Act to increase government support for the industry, and he weighed in on the issue on Wednesday. “Domestic semiconductor manufacturing has been steadily declining, and the Covid-19 pandemic has made clear how vulnerable our existing supply chains are,” the Republican senator from Texas said. “This report underscores the need to boost American production of semiconductors.”
Locating a plant in the US costs about 30% more over a decade than comparable sites in Taiwan, South Korea and Singapore. China may be as much as 50% cheaper, according to the report.
It takes as much as $20bn to build a big chip plant, considerably more than a new aircraft carrier or nuclear power plant, the report estimated.
Over a decade, semiconductor factories cost as much as $40bn. Government incentives about the world reduce that bill by up to $13bn, according to the report.
Most incentives in the US are provided by state governments that cannot compete against countries with bigger budgets, the SIA said. Some countries offer grants to make the required land free. Others slash corporate and property taxes or help with the cost of equipment purchases. The US ranks way down the list in most of those categories, many controlled by Washington, the group added.
Would you like to comment on this article or view other readers' comments?
Register (it’s quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.