Court orders government to clean up air in coal belt
Environment minister Barbara Creecy has a year to make regulations to put a clean air plan into effect
18 March 2022 - 15:35
UPDATED 18 March 2022 - 16:21
byTim Cocks
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
The high court in Pretoria upheld a complaint by activists on Friday that poor air quality in the coal belt is a breach of constitutional rights, giving the environment minister a year to enforce a clean air plan.
The coal belt, east of Pretoria and Johannesburg, is home to an estimated 3.6-million people, as well as a dozen Eskom coal-fired power stations and some Sasol petrochemicals plants.
Activists, scientists and doctors, as well as a UN human rights expert have argued that the epidemic of nasty respiratory diseases in the area is a direct result of high levels of air pollution. In a 2019 report, for the state-owned Council for Scientific and Industrial Research showed more than 5,000 South Africans die annually in the region because the government has failed to fully enforce its own air quality standards, and that a quarter of households there have children with asthma.
The court said environment minister Barbara Creecy had a legal duty to make regulations that enforced a government plan for cleaner air and that she had “unreasonably delayed” doing so.
A spokesperson for Creecy did not immediately respond to a request for comment. However, in her submission, the minister argued that while air pollution in the coal belt was indeed a problem, using the constitution to try to force the minister’s hand violated the separation of powers — an argument the court rejected.
The court ruling will require the government to take tougher action against heavy polluters such as liquid fuel producer Sasol and Eskom, which is drowning in debt and struggling to keep the lights on as it is.
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
Court orders government to clean up air in coal belt
Environment minister Barbara Creecy has a year to make regulations to put a clean air plan into effect
The high court in Pretoria upheld a complaint by activists on Friday that poor air quality in the coal belt is a breach of constitutional rights, giving the environment minister a year to enforce a clean air plan.
The coal belt, east of Pretoria and Johannesburg, is home to an estimated 3.6-million people, as well as a dozen Eskom coal-fired power stations and some Sasol petrochemicals plants.
Activists, scientists and doctors, as well as a UN human rights expert have argued that the epidemic of nasty respiratory diseases in the area is a direct result of high levels of air pollution. In a 2019 report, for the state-owned Council for Scientific and Industrial Research showed more than 5,000 South Africans die annually in the region because the government has failed to fully enforce its own air quality standards, and that a quarter of households there have children with asthma.
The court said environment minister Barbara Creecy had a legal duty to make regulations that enforced a government plan for cleaner air and that she had “unreasonably delayed” doing so.
A spokesperson for Creecy did not immediately respond to a request for comment. However, in her submission, the minister argued that while air pollution in the coal belt was indeed a problem, using the constitution to try to force the minister’s hand violated the separation of powers — an argument the court rejected.
The court ruling will require the government to take tougher action against heavy polluters such as liquid fuel producer Sasol and Eskom, which is drowning in debt and struggling to keep the lights on as it is.
Reuters
CLYDE RUSSELL: India eyes Russia’s coal as world eyeballs Russia
Support from banks for SA’s coal ambitions dwindles
Q&A: Greg Nichollas of Lesedi Nuclear Services on viable solutions to SA’s energy problems
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.
Most Read
Published by Arena Holdings and distributed with the Financial Mail on the last Thursday of every month except December and January.