Rio Tinto’s calamitous $3.7bn Mozambique coal deal still haunts them
Melbourne — Rio Tinto Group’s calamitous $3.7bn coal deal in Mozambique keeps coming back to haunt the world’s second-biggest miner, three years after it unloaded the mine.
US authorities filed fraud charges against London-based Rio, former CEO, Tom Albanese, and former chief financial officer, Guy Elliott, claiming they inflated the value of the coal assets acquired in 2011. The unit was sold for $50m in 2014 following impairments of about $2.9bn in 2013 and $470m a year later.
Rio concealed setbacks at the project and Albanese publicly reinforced a "false positive outlook" for the asset, according to a Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) complaint filed in federal court in New York. Executives told Albanese and Elliott that by May 2012 the Mozambique unit was likely "worth negative $680m", the SEC said.
"Rio Tinto intends to vigorously defend itself against these allegations," the company said in an e-mailed statement on the SEC charges. Albanese, Rio’s CEO between 2007 and 2013, said in a separate statement that "there is no truth in any of these charges." Elliott, who retired in 2013, also refuted the allegations in a statement issued on his behalf. He stood down as a non-executive director of Royal Dutch Shell, the company said in a statement on Wednesday.
Rio has also agreed to pay a £27.4m ($36m) fine for a breach of disclosure rules concerning the Mozambique assets, the UK’s Financial Conduct Authority said in a separate statement. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission is also reviewing the issue, the company said.
There’s an onus on chairman Jan du Plessis and the board to explain the issues around the SEC charges, Peter O’Connor, a Sydney-based analyst with Shaw and Partners, said in an e-mail on Wednesday.
The charges come as Rio assists authorities in three countries over a separate case related to the $20bn Simandou iron ore project in Guinea
Rio’s shares had declined 2.3% by 3.30pm in London, while rival BHP Billiton fell 1%.
The charges come as Rio assists authorities in three countries over a separate case related to the $20bn Simandou iron ore project in Guinea. Rio said in November it had alerted authorities, including the US department of justice and the UK’s serious fraud office, to a $10.5m payment to an external consultant made in 2011.
Rio’s 2011 acquisition of Riversdale Mining, holder of the Mozambique assets, came as the producer sought access to coking coal in the Moatize basin at a time the country was seeking to become a major supplier of the steel-making raw material.
The plans unraveled as the government refused to allow Rio to barge coal down the Zambezi and amid prohibitive costs of accessing or building rail lines to a port. Estimates of recoverable coking coal held by the assets were also downgraded, Rio said in 2013.
Albanese — who stepped down in August as CEO of Vedanta Resources — and Elliott, "allegedly breached their disclosure obligations and corporate duties by hiding from their board, auditor and investors the crucial fact that a multi-billion dollar transaction was a failure," Stephanie Avakian, co-director of the SEC’s enforcement division said in Wednesday’s statement. Shell declined to comment on the charges against Elliott.
Rio raised $5.5bn from US debt investors, including $3bn after May 2012, the SEC said.
Concerns over the carrying value of the coal assets were raised in January 2013 by an executive in Rio’s Technology and Innovation Group, allegedly triggering an internal review, the SEC said in its statement. Shortly after, Rio announced Albanese’s departure and the major write-down, the SEC said.
The SEC charges that, having already booked major write-downs following a takeover of Alcan, Albanese and Elliott knew that disclosing a second failure would "call into question their ability to pursue the core of Rio Tinto’s business model to identify and develop long-term, low-cost, and highly-profitable mining assets", according to the statement. Rio recorded more than $29bn of charges after paying $38bn in 2007 for aluminium producer Alcan, company filings show.
The UK’s FCA said Rio agreed to settle a breach of disclosure rules at an early stage and received a 30% reduction on its penalty. "The FCA made no findings of fraud, or of any systemic or widespread failure by Rio Tinto," Rio said in a Wednesday filing.