As Norway seeks to lessen mineral dependence on China, its move to open an offshore area for deep-sea mining faces domestic and international scrutiny
14 September 2023 - 09:21
byVictoria Klesty and Nerijus Adomaitis
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
Oslo — Norway may become the first country to start commercial deep-sea mining, if parliament approves a government proposal to open an offshore area larger than the UK, despite international calls for a global moratorium.
Parliament is set to discuss the government's bill this autumn.
Why does Norway want to extract seabed minerals?
The government says deep-sea mining could help Europe reduce its dependence on China for the supply of critical minerals needed to build electric vehicle (EV) batteries, wind turbines and solar panels.
It’s also a part of Norway’s strategy to develop new maritime industries, as its top export, oil and gas from offshore, is expected to decline gradually.
What does the government propose?
The Labour-led minority government has proposed to open about 280,000km2 of ocean areas between Jan Mayen Island and the Svalbard archipelago.
Its proposed plan follows similar principles to the opening of offshore areas to oil and gas exploration. From the overall area on offer, smaller zones, or blocks, would be offered to companies to explore and produce from.
While international rules for seabed mineral extraction are yet to be set, Norway doesn’t need to wait, because it plans to explore for minerals on its extended continental shelf.
What minerals does Norway want to extract from the seabed?
A government-sponsored survey found “substantial” amounts of metals and minerals, ranging from copper to rare earth elements.
Those minerals were found in polymetallic sulphides, or so-called “black smokers”, some 3,000m deep. It’s where seawater contacts magma coming up to the surface through tectonic cracks and then is flushed back carrying dissolved metals and sulphur.
Rare earth elements, such as scandium, were also found in manganese crusts, which grow on bedrock at a speed of 1cm per million years. Norwegian surveys have proven crust deposits with thicknesses of up to 40cm.
Is there life at the bottom of the seabed?
In depths of over 1,000m, there is no light, temperatures are near freezing and the water pressure is high.
Life does, however, exist and scientists have found unique species living around active hydrothermal vents, such as corals, tube worms and microorganisms. Little is known about how these ecosystems work.
What risks are there to the environment?
A government-commissioned study said the impact would be of a local nature, limited to the actual area being extracted. It also said the impact on fisheries would be minimal.
A government-sponsored survey found ‘substantial’ amounts of metals and minerals, ranging from copper to rare earth elements
Companies say they plan to extract minerals from inactive hydrothermal vents, where biodiversity is less abundant, but some scientists say they are concerned the practice could destroy the species even before they are discovered.
The government’s proposal has been criticised by some green groups, such as the World Wildlife Fund (WWF), but also by its own environmental agency, which said the gaps of knowledge about deep sea biology were too big to decide on the opening.
What do other countries say?
Denmark said Norway’s environmental study for the area opening was not good enough, while Iceland has questioned Norway’s exclusive rights to explore for seabed minerals near the Arctic Svalbard archipelago.
Norway is not part of the EU, but is a member of the European single market. The EU’s views on the issue are vital for Oslo’s plans, some analysts have said.
Norway is encouraged by EU ambitions to diversify imports of critical minerals and to boost local production.
However, the European Parliament has also called on member-states to support a global moratorium on seabed mining. The European Commission has been also advocating for a deep-sea mining moratorium until more is known about the risks.
How do you mine minerals from the seabed?
There is no commercially available technology to produce seabed minerals, though some machines have been built to test production elsewhere in the world.
Researchers in Norway used undersea robots and drilling machines to collect mineral samples at the ocean floor.
Extraction of minerals from the seabed in Norway would likely involve cutting and crushing the rocks before bringing those to surface.
Some Norwegian companies that provide technology and services to the oil industry are looking at deep sea mining as well.
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
Explainer: Norway’s plans to mine the seabed
As Norway seeks to lessen mineral dependence on China, its move to open an offshore area for deep-sea mining faces domestic and international scrutiny
Oslo — Norway may become the first country to start commercial deep-sea mining, if parliament approves a government proposal to open an offshore area larger than the UK, despite international calls for a global moratorium.
Parliament is set to discuss the government's bill this autumn.
Why does Norway want to extract seabed minerals?
The government says deep-sea mining could help Europe reduce its dependence on China for the supply of critical minerals needed to build electric vehicle (EV) batteries, wind turbines and solar panels.
It’s also a part of Norway’s strategy to develop new maritime industries, as its top export, oil and gas from offshore, is expected to decline gradually.
What does the government propose?
The Labour-led minority government has proposed to open about 280,000km2 of ocean areas between Jan Mayen Island and the Svalbard archipelago.
Its proposed plan follows similar principles to the opening of offshore areas to oil and gas exploration. From the overall area on offer, smaller zones, or blocks, would be offered to companies to explore and produce from.
While international rules for seabed mineral extraction are yet to be set, Norway doesn’t need to wait, because it plans to explore for minerals on its extended continental shelf.
What minerals does Norway want to extract from the seabed?
A government-sponsored survey found “substantial” amounts of metals and minerals, ranging from copper to rare earth elements.
Those minerals were found in polymetallic sulphides, or so-called “black smokers”, some 3,000m deep. It’s where seawater contacts magma coming up to the surface through tectonic cracks and then is flushed back carrying dissolved metals and sulphur.
Rare earth elements, such as scandium, were also found in manganese crusts, which grow on bedrock at a speed of 1cm per million years. Norwegian surveys have proven crust deposits with thicknesses of up to 40cm.
Is there life at the bottom of the seabed?
In depths of over 1,000m, there is no light, temperatures are near freezing and the water pressure is high.
Life does, however, exist and scientists have found unique species living around active hydrothermal vents, such as corals, tube worms and microorganisms. Little is known about how these ecosystems work.
What risks are there to the environment?
A government-commissioned study said the impact would be of a local nature, limited to the actual area being extracted. It also said the impact on fisheries would be minimal.
Companies say they plan to extract minerals from inactive hydrothermal vents, where biodiversity is less abundant, but some scientists say they are concerned the practice could destroy the species even before they are discovered.
The government’s proposal has been criticised by some green groups, such as the World Wildlife Fund (WWF), but also by its own environmental agency, which said the gaps of knowledge about deep sea biology were too big to decide on the opening.
What do other countries say?
Denmark said Norway’s environmental study for the area opening was not good enough, while Iceland has questioned Norway’s exclusive rights to explore for seabed minerals near the Arctic Svalbard archipelago.
Norway is not part of the EU, but is a member of the European single market. The EU’s views on the issue are vital for Oslo’s plans, some analysts have said.
Norway is encouraged by EU ambitions to diversify imports of critical minerals and to boost local production.
However, the European Parliament has also called on member-states to support a global moratorium on seabed mining. The European Commission has been also advocating for a deep-sea mining moratorium until more is known about the risks.
How do you mine minerals from the seabed?
There is no commercially available technology to produce seabed minerals, though some machines have been built to test production elsewhere in the world.
Researchers in Norway used undersea robots and drilling machines to collect mineral samples at the ocean floor.
Extraction of minerals from the seabed in Norway would likely involve cutting and crushing the rocks before bringing those to surface.
Some Norwegian companies that provide technology and services to the oil industry are looking at deep sea mining as well.
Reuters
Norway’s left-wing party demands Arctic mining halt
Norwegian court fines Meta for data harvesting
Norway wealth fund pushes for more women in boardrooms
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.
Most Read
Related Articles
Norway’s left-wing party demands Arctic mining halt
Weight-loss drug Wegovy launch in UK a shot at Lilly’s market share
Strikes to disrupt LNG projects at Chevron Australia
Published by Arena Holdings and distributed with the Financial Mail on the last Thursday of every month except December and January.