Venezuela is fast becoming a ‘mafia state’: here’s what you need to know
Beginning with Chávez and continuing under Maduro, Venezuela has evolved into a rampant kleptocracy
Last week, Nicolás Maduro was sworn in for his second six-year term as Venezuela’s president. Maduro won the election off the back of international condemnation of vote-buying and electoral fraud. While the US secretary of state Mike Pompeo called Venezuela’s government “illegitimate”, Maduro declared: “Venezuela is at the centre of a world war led by US imperialism and its satellite countries.”
Such statements have become par for the course by a leader and government determined to frame Venezuela’s political, social and economic woes as a product of a protracted ideological battle with the US.
While these discursive tactics may hold some traction with small parts of the population, the harsh reality of life in Venezuela and the government’s inability and, at times, unwillingness to address clear policy failings has significantly reduced support for Maduro and his government.
More than 100 Venezuelan government officials — ranging from, but not limited to, individuals in the ministries of the vice-president, defence, foreign affairs, intelligence and the national guard — have been implicated in criminal activity
The scale of Venezuela’s current social, economic and political crisis is so severe it is difficult to comprehend. Hyper-inflation has decimated the national currency and crippled the economy. Oil production — which accounts for 95% of the country’s export revenues — has halved since Maduro took power in 2013 and the industry has been further weakened by the collapse of the price of oil in 2014.
In 2018, the economy contracted by 18% and by the end of the year inflation had soared to 1-million percent. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has predicted inflation will increase to 10-million percent by the latter half of 2019. These are dizzying figures but they only reflect one part of the complex situation Venezuela is facing.
Across the country there are power cuts, food and medicine shortages, increasing internal security problems, rising homicide rates and widespread malnutrition. According to the UN, these factors have resulted in 3-million people fleeing the country since 2015, making it the largest exodus in Venezuelan history.
So how did it come to this?
The foundations of Maduro’s current problems date back to the death of Hugo Chávez in 2013. The spectacular rise in popularity of Chavismo, which promoted the cult of Chávez as the liberator of the Venezuelan people, became the vehicle in which Chávez successfully consolidated his legitimacy and the significant political changes made during his time in power from 1999 to 2013.
Chávez employed a charismatic leadership style that positioned himself as a man of the people rather than a member of the elite. He used transformation and transaction tactics to govern and maintain legitimacy. He was a keen orator and used his weekly TV programme to connect with the masses. Chavismo rests on socialist values and calls for an independent Latin America, free from the US.
While Maduro shares the same politics — and was the foreign minister in the Chávez government — his problems centre on his inability to emulate Chávez’s leadership style to generate the type of popular support and perceived legitimacy of his predecessor.
As a result, Maduro has increasingly sought to centralise power in the executive and systematically remove political rivals and members of the Venezuelan opposition from participating in democratic processes. For instance, he led the creation of a constituent assembly as a means to bypass the opposition-controlled national assembly.
His controversial changes to the 2018 presidential election, such as bringing it forward by six months to limit the time the opposition had to organise a strong campaign, as well as allegations of vote-tampering, point to the increasingly authoritarian tendencies of the regime.
However, Venezuela under Maduro has gone beyond simply transitioning to a more concentrated authoritarian-style rule. Venezuela has now morphed into what has been termed a “mafia state”.
Venezuela — the mafia state
A mafia state refers to a state that has effectively been criminalised. Here, criminal entities have successfully infiltrated and compromised government institutions at all levels. Currently, more than 100 Venezuelan government officials — ranging from, but not limited to, individuals in the ministries of the vice-president, defence, foreign affairs, intelligence and the national guard — have been implicated in criminal activity.
The clearest example of the complex nexus between criminality and the Venezuelan state has been the emergence of a powerful Venezuelan drug-trafficking organisation known as the Cartel of the Suns. The organisation’s name is a reference to the gold stars on epaulettes of military generals, but is more generally symbolic of the direct links between serving government officials and the drug-trafficking organisation.
Former vice-president Tarek el-Aissami and former president of the national assembly Diosdado Cabello, are allegedly involved in the Cartel of the Suns and are among a litany of Venezuelan officials who have had sanctions imposed on them by the US.
Venezuela’s first lady, Celia Flores, is also implicated by association. Her nephews have been convicted of trafficking cocaine in the US and, according to Insight Crime, Flores’s son is also under investigation in relation to drug-trafficking activities.
Beginning with Chávez and continuing under Maduro, Venezuela has evolved into a rampant kleptocracy. The systematic removal of transparency and accountability in the Venezuela political system has allowed tens of billions of dollars to disappear from the treasury over the past two decades.
For example, in November 2018 a former Chávez bodyguard, who later went on to become the treasurer of Venezuela, pled guilty to receiving more than $1bn in bribes.
Venezuela’s outlook is bleak. The opposition remains fractured but continues to dispute Maduro’s legitimacy and right to govern, and it appears to be almost impossible for the opposition to pressure Maduro to negotiate while he continues to enjoy the support of the Venezuelan military.
At this point, the parties have reached an impasse and if current trends continue, things will get much worse in Venezuela before they can have a chance of getting better.
This article first appeared in the Conversation.