Talking up to one another rather than down is a good way to get on in our land of many languages
11 November 2021 - 05:00
byPaul Ash
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
More than words: uMngeni mayor-elect Chris Pappas. Picture: Facebook
Early on in An Ordinary People, filmmaker Ernest Nkosi’s mesmerising documentary about car spinning, we meet an unforgettable character named Bradleigh "Skopas" McGregor. He is a spinner with a buzzcut and heavily inked arms, and introduces himself thus:
"It’s not that I hate white people. It’s just that black people have always been better to me." Or something like that.
It shouldn’t matter that McGregor is a white guy and that throughout the documentary he speaks only fluent Zulu. Except it does.
Cue the DA’s Chris Pappas, the uMngeni mayor-elect, whose video of him explaining how he learnt to speak fluent Zulu has gone viral. It shouldn’t matter, but it does.
The mines once used Fanakalo to communicate with workers who came from all over Southern Africa. It drew heavily on Zulu, along with a smattering of English and Afrikaans.
The language was so basic that it was estimated that workers would need no more than 15 hours of instruction to become fluent in it, no matter where they were from.
The problem with Fanakalo is not only that it is an abomination of a language but also that it is only a language of instruction. Not so much "please, may I ask you to …" as "come here now".
So to see politicians communicating with the people in their metros in their own tongue — without merely assuming that everyone should just speak English — gives me more hope than any state capture commission or fresh cabinet appointment or the sight of engineers fixing a broken water main has ever done.
Language does matter. Fixing SA means getting back to the basics, and a good start would be speaking up to people instead of talking down to them.
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
Mother tongue is better than Big Daddy
Talking up to one another rather than down is a good way to get on in our land of many languages
Early on in An Ordinary People, filmmaker Ernest Nkosi’s mesmerising documentary about car spinning, we meet an unforgettable character named Bradleigh "Skopas" McGregor. He is a spinner with a buzzcut and heavily inked arms, and introduces himself thus:
"It’s not that I hate white people. It’s just that black people have always been better to me." Or something like that.
It shouldn’t matter that McGregor is a white guy and that throughout the documentary he speaks only fluent Zulu. Except it does.
Cue the DA’s Chris Pappas, the uMngeni mayor-elect, whose video of him explaining how he learnt to speak fluent Zulu has gone viral. It shouldn’t matter, but it does.
The mines once used Fanakalo to communicate with workers who came from all over Southern Africa. It drew heavily on Zulu, along with a smattering of English and Afrikaans.
The language was so basic that it was estimated that workers would need no more than 15 hours of instruction to become fluent in it, no matter where they were from.
The problem with Fanakalo is not only that it is an abomination of a language but also that it is only a language of instruction. Not so much "please, may I ask you to …" as "come here now".
So to see politicians communicating with the people in their metros in their own tongue — without merely assuming that everyone should just speak English — gives me more hope than any state capture commission or fresh cabinet appointment or the sight of engineers fixing a broken water main has ever done.
Language does matter. Fixing SA means getting back to the basics, and a good start would be speaking up to people instead of talking down to them.
MICHAEL EVANS: Cranky coalitions are not the only way to share power
BIG READ: Is this the beginning of the end of the ANC?
CAROL PATON: Is this the political realignment the DA has been waiting for?
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.
Most Read
Published by Arena Holdings and distributed with the Financial Mail on the last Thursday of every month except December and January.