Foreign firms warn Vietnam of investment freeze without new tax offset

Hanoi — Large foreign multinationals say they may freeze new investment plans in Vietnam in the absence of subsidies to help offset the cost of a new top-up tax, says a person involved in talks on the matter between investors and the government.

The investment-reliant manufacturing hub has been one of the main beneficiaries of companies relocating activity from China to minimise the impact of Sino-US tension. But a tax hike alongside power supply problems, regulatory hurdles and wage increases may dent its competitiveness, analysts have said.

Vietnam this year introduced the 15% global minimum tax on large multinationals, an initiative shepherded by the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). In accordance, incentives that lowered tax rates to as little as 5% will no longer be available, meaning some multinationals will effectively have to pay a top-up tax to meet the 15% rate.

Some US multinationals had called on the government to honour low-tax commitments it made to attract existing investment, adding that new investment would be difficult without measures to offset the top-up, the person said.

The government pledged new subsidies in the first half of last year but has been slow to introduce any.

In December, it released a draft decree outlining new subsidies and conditions for eligibility, such as being classed as a high-technology company. But many key aspects remain undefined, such as the size of a new incentives fund, and there is no clear timetable for approval of the measures.

Representatives of multinationals on Tuesday raised concerns with officials of the ministry of planning & investment about the size, scope and accessibility of the planned incentives, the person, who attended the meeting, told Reuters on condition of anonymity as the meeting was not public.

A representative for Lego Group, which is investing over $1bn to build a new factory in Vietnam, asked whether firms not classed as hi-tech such as Lego would be eligible for any of the subsidies outlined under the draft decree, to which a ministry official replied they would not, the person said.

The Danish toy maker confirmed that one of its representatives asked a question on the matter in the meeting.

A representative for US firm Amkor Technology, which is building in Vietnam a $1.6bn plant to assemble, test and package semiconductors, said it had struggled to obtain classification as a hi-tech company, the person said.

Representatives for Samsung Electronics, the largest foreign investor, did not intervene in the meeting, the person said. The South Korean company has been among the most vocal about measures to offset the increased tax burden.

Amkor Technology and the ministry of planning & investment did not respond to requests for comment. Samsung declined to comment.

Through the top-up tax, the government has estimated additional annual tax revenue of 14.6 trillion dong ($591m) from 122 foreign companies. It has said it intended to use this windfall to give cash handouts to investing companies.

Still, new subsidies would not offer direct compensation for the increased tax burden, in line with the global minimum tax initiative, government officials told the corporate representatives on Tuesday, according to the person.

A direct link would breach the international agreement behind the initiative and could lead to the transfer of the additional revenue to multinationals' home countries, OECD officials have said, though enforcement measures remain unclear.

However, for some companies, the new subsidies could cover a large part — if not all — of the top-up tax costs, experts familiar with discussions on the incentives have said.

Reuters