Gaborone — Ninety elephant carcasses have been discovered in Botswana with their tusks hacked off, Elephants Without Borders says, but the government is fiercely contesting that figure.
The charity group said on Tuesday that the grim discovery of scores of elephant carcasses, made over several weeks during an aerial survey, is believed to be one of Africa’s worst mass poaching sprees.
The charity’s scientists, who carried out the assessment with Botswana’s Department of Wildlife and National Parks, found most of the dead animals were large bulls, which would have had heavy tusks.
"We started flying the survey on July 10, and we have counted 90 elephant carcasses since the survey commenced," Mike Chase, the charity’s director, told AFP.
"Each day we are counting dead elephants."
The elephants were shot with heavy-calibre rifles at watering spots near a popular wildlife sanctuary in the Okavango Delta.
According to Chase, the carcasses’ skulls were "chopped open by presumably very sharp axes, to remove their tusks". In some cases the trunks were also removed.
"The scale of elephant poaching is by far the largest I have seen or read about in Africa to date," Chase said.
It coincided with Botswana’s rangers being reportedly disarmed earlier this year, he said.
But the Botswana government later rejected the charity’s tally of the carcasses as well as their explanation for the deaths.
"These statistics are false and misleading," said a statement on the official government Twitter account. It said that "at no point in the last months or recently were 87 or 90 elephants killed in one incident in any place in Botswana".
It said Elephants Without Borders had counted 53 carcasses during the survey, and it had verified that most of these animals had died of "natural causes".
The statement confirmed that authorities had withdrawn weapons from rangers, but denied the move had "created any vacuum in anti-poaching operations".
"Government wishes to reiterate the fact that wildlife remains a national heritage and our citizens will protect it at all costs," it said.
Botswana previously had a zero-tolerance approach to poaching, with a "shoot-to-kill" policy against poachers.
The country, with its unfenced parks and wide open spaces, has the largest elephant population in Africa at over 135,000.
Earlier Botswana Tourism Minister Tshekedi Khama confirmed to AFP that elephants had been poached.
"I am very concerned, it’s a huge worry," he said. "I’m aware that the numbers are in double digits, and for Botswana they are high.
"Because we had been spared poaching for a long time, I think now we are realising the sophistication of these poachers.
"Unfortunately sometimes we learn these lessons the hard way," he said.
Chase said elephants in Zambia and Angola, north of Botswana, "have been poached to the verge of local extinction, and poachers have now turned to Botswana".
The number of African elephants has fallen by about 111,000 to 415,000 in the past decade, according to the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN).
The killing continues at a dizzying pace of about 30,000 elephants a year to meet demand for ivory in Asia, where tusks sell for about $1,000/kg.
The Botswana poaching occurred just months after former president Ian Khama, who is deeply passionate about protecting wildlife, stepped down, handing power to his chosen successor, Mokgweetsi Masisi.
Global conservationist International Fund for Animal Welfare (IFAW) expressed shock at the slaughter.
"Until now Botswana’s elephant herds have largely been left in peace, but clearly Botswana is now in the cross-hairs," said Jason Bell, IFAW’s vice president for conservation.
Poachers have also targeted rhino in Botswana, with six white rhino carcasses were found in recent months.