A reader says Sars does not seem to take previous payments into account when he reinvests the interest on his investment
18 July 2024 - 05:00
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
My question involves R3m invested in five-year fixed-deposit South African retail bonds at the current interest (10.5%), with no withdrawals but reinvested interest. I’d like to know about tax.
The interest is (after an allowance of R34,500) added to my taxable income. So I pay tax on the interest. Happy so far!
Now I reinvest the interest, making the capital sum R3.315m. Does the interest remain at 10.5%? Not considered a new investment, the interest in the next year is R348,075, which is again added to my taxable income in the second year. But I have already paid tax on the R315,000 in the year before.
Is there an allowance with the South African Revenue Service (Sars) regarding tax in the second year and so on?
— Mike B
Answer:
The allowance mentioned is correct for those over 65. For savers under 65 the annual interest exemption is R24,800 per year.
As to the question: yes, the interest rate would remain the same, in this case 10.5%, but on a higher capital amount, as you’ve reinvested the interest, essentially adding it to the capital.
Sars does not credit you with the tax paid in the previous year on the interest received. It treats it as new interest income, which it is, and so, yes, there is a drag on the return. Further, as you reinvested the interest, you owed tax but had not received any cash flow, so you’d have to pay the tax out of other money you have.
It may well be worth speaking to a tax expert about the matter to try to reduce your interest taxation with other products — maybe even a tax-free or regulation 28 product.
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
READER QUESTION OF THE WEEK
YOUR MONEY: Must I pay tax on interest twice?
A reader says Sars does not seem to take previous payments into account when he reinvests the interest on his investment
Question:
My question involves R3m invested in five-year fixed-deposit South African retail bonds at the current interest (10.5%), with no withdrawals but reinvested interest. I’d like to know about tax.
The interest is (after an allowance of R34,500) added to my taxable income. So I pay tax on the interest. Happy so far!
Now I reinvest the interest, making the capital sum R3.315m. Does the interest remain at 10.5%? Not considered a new investment, the interest in the next year is R348,075, which is again added to my taxable income in the second year. But I have already paid tax on the R315,000 in the year before.
Is there an allowance with the South African Revenue Service (Sars) regarding tax in the second year and so on?
— Mike B
Answer:
The allowance mentioned is correct for those over 65. For savers under 65 the annual interest exemption is R24,800 per year.
As to the question: yes, the interest rate would remain the same, in this case 10.5%, but on a higher capital amount, as you’ve reinvested the interest, essentially adding it to the capital.
Sars does not credit you with the tax paid in the previous year on the interest received. It treats it as new interest income, which it is, and so, yes, there is a drag on the return. Further, as you reinvested the interest, you owed tax but had not received any cash flow, so you’d have to pay the tax out of other money you have.
It may well be worth speaking to a tax expert about the matter to try to reduce your interest taxation with other products — maybe even a tax-free or regulation 28 product.
— Simon Brown, Just One Lap
We’d like to hear from you. E-mail us on yourmoney@fm.co.za
YOUR MONEY: Retail bonds are as safe as can be
YOUR MONEY: Providing for family while estate is wound up
YOUR MONEY: Sound tips for a rookie investor
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.
Most Read
Published by Arena Holdings and distributed with the Financial Mail on the last Thursday of every month except December and January.