The end of a two-decade occupation: America’s undignified exit from Afghanistan
19 August 2021 - 05:00
byPaul Ash
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
William Brydon, assistant surgeon in the British East India Company Army, arriving at Jalalabad on January 13 1842
A wise general named Alexander the Great once said that Afghanistan was "easy to march into, hard to march out of".
No kidding. Just ask anyone who has had the unfortunate honour: Lord Elphinstone, British Empire, killed by Afghan tribesmen during his retreat from Kabul in 1842; General Boris V Gromov, Russian, last soldier across the frontier at the end of the Soviet Union’s failed invasion, February 1989; and now, Joe Biden, 46th president of the US, who, right or wrong, will take the fall — literally — for America’s undignified exit from the graveyard of empires.
Never mind that Biden is merely accelerating his predecessor’s policy to withdraw from a 20-year occupation that has cost 2,400 American lives and $2-trillion — the defeat will be his.
The "optics", which are already bad, get worse considering that the Taliban — who have taken Kabul after a breathtaking blitzkrieg — do not have an inspiring human rights record.
No wonder, then that Kabul airport has been overrun by desperate civilians, begging to be put on flights out. No-one, least of all the people of Kabul who have enjoyed the occasional peace and vague stability that comes from having the world’s policeman as your landlord, is deluded enough to think that the Taliban won’t reverse policies enacted by the occupiers, like, you know, letting girls go to high school.
For a graphic depiction of the folly of invading Afghanistan, look no further than the paintings of William Brydon, assistant surgeon in the British East India Company Army, being carried into Jalalabad on the back of his exhausted horse on January 13 1842.
Brydon was one of a handful of survivors of Lord Elphinstone’s 4,500-strong army, which in less than a week had been whittled away by hit-and-run attacks by tribesmen tougher than the mountains they called home.
And here we are again. If only they had all listened to Alexander.
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
The graveyard of empires strikes back
The end of a two-decade occupation: America’s undignified exit from Afghanistan
A wise general named Alexander the Great once said that Afghanistan was "easy to march into, hard to march out of".
No kidding. Just ask anyone who has had the unfortunate honour: Lord Elphinstone, British Empire, killed by Afghan tribesmen during his retreat from Kabul in 1842; General Boris V Gromov, Russian, last soldier across the frontier at the end of the Soviet Union’s failed invasion, February 1989; and now, Joe Biden, 46th president of the US, who, right or wrong, will take the fall — literally — for America’s undignified exit from the graveyard of empires.
Never mind that Biden is merely accelerating his predecessor’s policy to withdraw from a 20-year occupation that has cost 2,400 American lives and $2-trillion — the defeat will be his.
The "optics", which are already bad, get worse considering that the Taliban — who have taken Kabul after a breathtaking blitzkrieg — do not have an inspiring human rights record.
No wonder, then that Kabul airport has been overrun by desperate civilians, begging to be put on flights out. No-one, least of all the people of Kabul who have enjoyed the occasional peace and vague stability that comes from having the world’s policeman as your landlord, is deluded enough to think that the Taliban won’t reverse policies enacted by the occupiers, like, you know, letting girls go to high school.
For a graphic depiction of the folly of invading Afghanistan, look no further than the paintings of William Brydon, assistant surgeon in the British East India Company Army, being carried into Jalalabad on the back of his exhausted horse on January 13 1842.
Brydon was one of a handful of survivors of Lord Elphinstone’s 4,500-strong army, which in less than a week had been whittled away by hit-and-run attacks by tribesmen tougher than the mountains they called home.
And here we are again. If only they had all listened to Alexander.
Biden blames Afghan leaders for Taliban chaos
IAN BREMMER: This is how US incompetence led to Afghanistan horror
How Taliban benefits from Afghanistan’s drug trade
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.
Most Read
Related Articles
Evacuation flights continue from Kabul airport
EU tells Taliban humanitarian aid will flow only if human rights are respected
SA has been in contact with several citizens in Afghanistan
All is peaceful in Taliban-controlled Afghanistan, Taliban asserts
Afghanistan’s collapse a blow to Joe Biden as Taliban overrun Kabul
Afghan president flees as Taliban fighters have Kabul in their grasp
Ashraf Ghani was supposed to fix Afghanistan
Published by Arena Holdings and distributed with the Financial Mail on the last Thursday of every month except December and January.