Coalition government’s collapse comes as country faces multiple headwinds
12 November 2024 - 19:39
by Andreas Rinke and Thomas Escritt
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
German Chancellor Olaf Scholz at the Bundestag, Germany's lower house of parliament, in Berlin, Germany, November 12 2024. Picture: REUTERS/LISI NIESNER
Berlin — Germany is set to hold snap elections on February 23 after the collapse of Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s governing coalition, but officials warned on Tuesday it would leave the 2025 budget and several other policy initiatives in limbo.
The election date is a compromise between the conservative opposition, who wanted a vote in January for fear of leaving Germany rudderless, and Scholz, who wanted a mid-March election to give authorities and parties more time to prepare.
Inflation, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, intensifying competition from China and US President-elect Donald Trump’s return have combined to confront Germany whose economy, Europe’s biggest, prospered from abundant energy, and a benign, pro-trade international political environment.
Reflecting that, the ZEW institute’s investor morale index tumbled to 7.4 points on Tuesday from 13.1 points in October, a much sharper drop than analysts had expected.
A government with a clear majority would be better able to broach topics such as the country’s debt brake, blamed by many economists for the low investment rate, or to make money available for important industries.
The February 23 date is predicated on Scholz holding a confidence vote on December 16 that he would be expected to lose.
A leader in Scholz’s Social Democrats said the party stood by the chancellor and brushed away suggestions that Scholz should step side for another candidate, such as the more popular defence minister Boris Pistorius.
“Now it’s about experience and competence and I am sure that Olaf Scholz is the right candidate,” SPD parliamentary group leader Rolf Muetzenich said.
Scholz conveys “trust, competence, experience, but at the same time also the necessary emotions”, he said.
Closing window
Scholz, who now runs a minority government with the backing of the Greens, hopes to secure enough opposition support to pass laws to protect the Constitutional Court from the far right and to boost funding for Ukraine before leaving office.
His government collapsed last week after months of wrangling between the two remaining parties and their erstwhile coalition partner, the neoliberal Free Democrats, who demanded spending cuts on a scale their left-wing partners were unwilling to countenance.
Friedrich Merz, leader of the opposition Christian Democrats and favourite in current polls to become chancellor, has so far ruled out scrapping the debt brake.
On Tuesday, he promised a major tax reform but was non-committal on helping the government pass all but the most pressing legislation between now and the election.
That means raising child benefits or tax thresholds to tackle fiscal drag might have to wait until a new government is in power.
Joerg Kukies, who was appointed finance minister after Scholz sacked his one-time coalition ally Christian Lindner over budget disputes, said passing a 2025 budget was not realistic.
“It’s not the end of the world,” he said.
He added that a strategy on power plants would have to wait but that the government would stick to plans to reprivatise energy company Uniper, which was rescued during the energy crisis after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022.
He also echoed the government’s criticism of Milan-headquartered Unicredit’s mooted takeover of German lender Commerzbank, saying the European banking system didn’t need such aggressive takeovers.
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
Germany heads for February snap election
Coalition government’s collapse comes as country faces multiple headwinds
Berlin — Germany is set to hold snap elections on February 23 after the collapse of Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s governing coalition, but officials warned on Tuesday it would leave the 2025 budget and several other policy initiatives in limbo.
The election date is a compromise between the conservative opposition, who wanted a vote in January for fear of leaving Germany rudderless, and Scholz, who wanted a mid-March election to give authorities and parties more time to prepare.
Inflation, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, intensifying competition from China and US President-elect Donald Trump’s return have combined to confront Germany whose economy, Europe’s biggest, prospered from abundant energy, and a benign, pro-trade international political environment.
Reflecting that, the ZEW institute’s investor morale index tumbled to 7.4 points on Tuesday from 13.1 points in October, a much sharper drop than analysts had expected.
A government with a clear majority would be better able to broach topics such as the country’s debt brake, blamed by many economists for the low investment rate, or to make money available for important industries.
The February 23 date is predicated on Scholz holding a confidence vote on December 16 that he would be expected to lose.
A leader in Scholz’s Social Democrats said the party stood by the chancellor and brushed away suggestions that Scholz should step side for another candidate, such as the more popular defence minister Boris Pistorius.
“Now it’s about experience and competence and I am sure that Olaf Scholz is the right candidate,” SPD parliamentary group leader Rolf Muetzenich said.
Scholz conveys “trust, competence, experience, but at the same time also the necessary emotions”, he said.
Closing window
Scholz, who now runs a minority government with the backing of the Greens, hopes to secure enough opposition support to pass laws to protect the Constitutional Court from the far right and to boost funding for Ukraine before leaving office.
His government collapsed last week after months of wrangling between the two remaining parties and their erstwhile coalition partner, the neoliberal Free Democrats, who demanded spending cuts on a scale their left-wing partners were unwilling to countenance.
Friedrich Merz, leader of the opposition Christian Democrats and favourite in current polls to become chancellor, has so far ruled out scrapping the debt brake.
On Tuesday, he promised a major tax reform but was non-committal on helping the government pass all but the most pressing legislation between now and the election.
That means raising child benefits or tax thresholds to tackle fiscal drag might have to wait until a new government is in power.
Joerg Kukies, who was appointed finance minister after Scholz sacked his one-time coalition ally Christian Lindner over budget disputes, said passing a 2025 budget was not realistic.
“It’s not the end of the world,” he said.
He added that a strategy on power plants would have to wait but that the government would stick to plans to reprivatise energy company Uniper, which was rescued during the energy crisis after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022.
He also echoed the government’s criticism of Milan-headquartered Unicredit’s mooted takeover of German lender Commerzbank, saying the European banking system didn’t need such aggressive takeovers.
Reuters
MICHAEL AVERY: Will the bond vigilantes manage to contain Trump 2.0?
ANALYSIS: German government collapse could have silver lining for Europe’s markets
SAM MKOKELI: Trumpian anarchy set to be loosed upon the world
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.
Most Read
Related Articles
German industry calls for fast snap election
Infighting, bleak economy move Germany’s coalition to shaky ground
German workers stage nationwide strikes
Volkswagen labour chief sounds alarm on mass layoffs and three plant closures
Co-leaders of Germany’s Greens quit amid poll woes
Olaf Scholz’s SPD fends off Germany’s far right in state vote, exit polls show
Published by Arena Holdings and distributed with the Financial Mail on the last Thursday of every month except December and January.