Braverman under fire for pro-Palestinian ‘hate marches’ comment
Braverman may have crossed the line, critics say
London — British home secretary Suella Braverman escalated a dispute with London’s police force on Thursday over the handling of a planned, large pro-Palestinian march on Armistice Day, accusing officers of taking a softer stance towards left-wing causes.
Braverman has taken a tough line on the tens of thousands of protesters who have gathered in London since the Hamas group’s October 7 attack on Israel, calling them “hate marches” and “mobs” that threaten the Jewish community.
Her criticism of the police ahead of Saturday deepened tensions with Prime Minister Rishi Sunak’s Downing Street office, which said it had not cleared the comments before publication. Yet a spokesperson said Sunak still had full confidence in Braverman.
“I do not believe that these marches are merely a cry for help for Gaza,” Braverman, who is on the right of her party and in charge of policing, wrote in The Times. “They are an assertion of primacy by certain groups — particularly Islamists — of the kind we are more used to seeing in Northern Ireland.
She said there was “a perception that senior police officers play favourites when it comes to protesters”, citing what she said was the contrasting treatment of anti-lockdown groups during the Covid-19 pandemic, and Black Lives Matters demonstrations.
Critics in opposing parties and her own accuse Braverman of stoking division and undermining the police. They question her commitment to free speech after she asked why some public gatherings should not be banned when they are offensive.
The issue came to a head after police said they expected a large rally on Saturday, the anniversary of the end of World War 1, prompting fears that counter-protesters would also descend on the capital, leading to violence.
London police chief Mark Rowley has said any ban would require intelligence of a threat of serious disorder and that so far that threshold had not been crossed.
Protesters have gathered in London every weekend to demand a halt to Israel's aerial and ground offensive against Hamas-ruled Gaza, with about 100,000 the largest number marshalled so far.
While there has been little overt violence, banners appearing to celebrate the cross-border Hamas attack — in which 1,400 Israelis were killed, mainly civilians — have been seen and the chant of “From the river to the sea” heard, a pro-Palestinian rallying cry that is viewed by many Jews as anti-Semitic and calling for Israel’s eradication.
In total since October 7, police say they have arrested nearly 200 people for acts of anti-Semitism, Islamophobia and public order offences such as letting off fireworks towards officers.
Sunak has described the march as disrespectful and said he would hold Rowley to account that the remembrance events are safeguarded.
But he said Britain must remain true to the principles it fought for during two world wars, including the right to peacefully protest and to free speech “even if we disagree”.
Braverman, seen as a possible future Conservative Party leader, often takes a harder line than many in her party on issues such as crime and immigration. She recently described being homeless as a “lifestyle” choice.
A government source said Downing Street officials saw a draft of the article and suggested changes that were not incorporated.
Opposition Labour Party leader Keir Starmer said Sunak was too weak to challenge her, and Yvette Cooper, Labour’s shadow home secretary, said Braverman was “out of control”.
Some centrist Conservative MPs called for her dismissal. Even those on the Right of the party said she should be more careful with her language, saying the reference to Northern Ireland would alienate those who held civil rights marches and pro-British Loyalist rallies in the past.
Neil Basu, a former senior London police officer, said the political criticism could increase the risk of violence.
“It’s somewhat ironic that all of this rhetoric about this march might actually be increasing the intelligence case, to have it banned,” he told LBC Radio. Two men were arrested for defacing the Cenotaph war memorial with “Free Palestine” in the northern English town of Rochdale this week.
Organisers have said they do not plan to march in London on Sunday when political leaders join King Charles and members of the military to remember those who have died in war at a sombre annual ceremony.