Russian troops doomed to fail in Ukraine, says former mercenary
People in Moscow security circles are speaking up about the war being waged incompetently
Neuilly-sur-Seine — The Russian military’s failure to seize the Ukrainian capital was inevitable because in the preceding years they had never directly faced a powerful enemy, according to a former mercenary with the Kremlin-linked Wagner Group who fought alongside the Russian army.
Marat Gabidullin took part in Wagner missions on the Kremlin’s behalf in Syria and in a previous conflict in Ukraine, before deciding to go public about his experience inside the secretive private military company.
He quit the group in 2019 but several months before Russia launched the invasion on February 24 Gabidullin said he received a call from a recruiter who invited him to go back to fighting as a mercenary in Ukraine.
He refused, in part because he knew Russian forces were not up to the job, even though they trumpeted their arsenal of new weapons and their successes in Syria where they helped President Bashar al-Assad defeat an armed rebellion.
“They were caught completely by surprise that the Ukrainian army resisted so fiercely and that they faced the actual army,” Gabidullin said about Russia’s setbacks in Ukraine.
People he spoke to on the Russian side told him they expected to face rag-tag militias when they invaded Ukraine, not well-drilled regular troops, he said.
“I told them: ‘Guys, that’s a mistake’,” said Gabidullin, who is now in France where he is publishing a book about his experiences fighting with the Wagner Group.
Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said he did not know who Gabidullin is and whether he has ever been a member of private military companies. “We, the state, the government, the Kremlin cannot have anything to do with it.”
The Russian defence ministry did not respond to a request for comment.
Russia calls its actions in Ukraine a “special operation” that it says is not designed to occupy territory but to destroy its southern neighbour’s military capabilities and capture what it regards as dangerous nationalists.
Gabidullin is part of a small but growing cohort of people in Russia with security backgrounds who have supported President Vladimir Putin’s foreign incursions but now say the way the war is being conducted is incompetent.
Igor Girkin, who helped lead a pro-Kremlin armed revolt in eastern Ukraine in 2014, has been critical of the way this campaign is being conducted. Alexei Alexandrov, an architect of the 2014 rebellion, told Reuters in March the invasion was a mistake.
Gabidullin took part in some of the bloodiest Syrian clashes in Deir al-Zor province, in Ghouta and near the ancient city of Palmyra. He was injured in 2016 when a grenade exploded behind his back during a battle in the mountains near Latakia.
Gabidullin spent a week in a coma and three months in a hospital where he had surgery to remove one of his kidneys and some intestines. Reuters has independently verified he was in the Wagner Group and was in combat in Syria.
Wagner fighters have been accused by rights groups and the Ukrainian government of committing war crimes in Syria and eastern Ukraine from 2014 onwards. Gabidullin said he was never involved in such abuses.
Moscow’s involvement helped turn the tide of the Syrian war in favour of al-Assad, but Gabidullin said Russia’s military restricted itself mainly to attacks from the air, while relying on Wagner mercenaries and other proxies to do the lion’s share of the fighting on the ground.
The Russian military’s task was easier too. Its opponents — Islamic State and other militias — had no anti-aircraft systems or artillery. Fighting Ukraine, he said, is a different proposition.
“I’ve seen enough of them in Syria ... [The Russian military] didn’t take part in combat directly,” he said in an interview in Paris to promote his book, which will be published by French publishing house Michel Lafon in May.
“The military forces ... when it was needed to learn how to fight, did not learn how to fight for real,” he said.
Wagner Group is an informal entity, with — on paper at least — no offices or staff. The US treasury department and the EU have said the group is linked to Russian businessman Yevgeny Prigozhin. He has denied any such links.
Concord Management and Consulting, Prigozhin’s main business, did not respond to a request for comment.
President Vladimir Putin has said private military contractors have the right to work and pursue their interests anywhere in the world as long as they do not break Russian law. He has said the Wagner Group neither represents the Russian state nor is paid by it.
Gabidullin said though he knew the Russian invasion of Ukraine was coming, he did not expect it to be on such a scale. “I could not even think that Russia will wage a war on Ukraine. How could that be? It’s impossible,” he said.
Would you like to comment on this article or view other readers' comments?
Register (it’s quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.