Oxfam warns farmers and workers bear the brunt of cheap food
Paris — Supermarkets in the West are using their purchasing power to force suppliers to cut their prices, contributing to exploitation and even forced labour of millions of farmers worldwide, a global charity said on Thursday.
"Millions of women and men who produce our food are trapped in poverty and face brutal working conditions, despite billion-dollar profits in the food industry," Oxfam International said as it released a report titled Ripe for Change.
"From forced labour aboard fishing vessels in Southeast Asia, to poverty wages on Indian tea plantations and hunger faced by workers on South African grape farms, human and labour rights abuses are all too common in food supply chains," the report said.
In surveys conducted in five countries in 2017, Oxfam said it documented what it called "unfair trading practices" by supermarket giants, such as setting prices below the cost of sustainable production. They were also unwilling to raise prices in order to take into account increases in the minimum wage, it said.
Such practices left the workers at the bottom of the supply chain to pay the heaviest price.
In Thailand, more than 90% of workers at seafood processing plants said they had gone without enough food the previous month, Oxfam said.
In Italy, where many farm workers are migrants, 75% of women working on fruit and vegetable farms said they or a family member had to miss meals because they could not afford to buy enough food.
"It is one of the cruellest paradoxes of our time that the people producing our food and their families are often going without enough to eat themselves," Oxfam said.
The charity criticised major European and US supermarkets for failing to ensure food producers were treated with dignity. Part of the reason inequality was increasing, Oxfam said, was the drive by supermarket chains to deliver year-round choice at a low cost.
"The eight largest publicly owned supermarkets in the world generated some $1- trillion from sales in 2016 and nearly $22bn in profit," Oxfam said. It plans to launch a campaign to urge supermarkets to "crack down on inhumane working conditions".
"Supermarkets can afford to pay producers a fair price without burdening shoppers," said Winnie Byanyima, Oxfam’s executive director. "In many cases, giving back just 1% or 2% of the retail price — a few cents — would be life-changing for the women and men who produce the food on their shelves."
Oxfam noted that France’s Carrefour, the leading retailer in Europe, in 2016 generated a net profit of €894m and paid out €510m in dividends.
If the retailer had paid 1% of that sum to Vietnamese shrimp workers, more than 14,200 workers would have made a living wage, Oxfam said.
Reactions from major European retailers were mixed, with Edeka, Germany’s biggest supermarket chain, saying it "rejected" Oxfam’s conclusions.
"The evaluation lacks transparency, which is why we cannot make sense of it. This is a campaign and not a scientific and objective study," Edeka said.
Lidl and Aldi both said they would study the report to identify possible shortcomings in their practices.
The British Retail Consortium, which represents the main players in the sector, also said it welcomed Oxfam’s recommendations.
"Our members have made a number of commitments to improve the livelihoods of people working in our supply chains and to increase the transparency of those efforts," it said. The UK retail industry was "one of the most progressive in this area, globally", it said.