Japan’s contaminated Moderna vaccines: what we know
31 August 2021 - 08:40
byRocky Swift
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
Medical staff prepares the Moderna Covid-19 vaccine in Tokyo, Japan, in this May 24 2021 file photo. Picture: POOL via REUTERS/CARL COURT
Tokyo — Japan’s Covid-19 vaccination push suffered a blow from widening reports of contamination in supplies of American pharmaceutical and biotechnology company Moderna’s vaccine. Here are key aspects of the concerns.
When was it first reported and how has it widened?
The first contamination was reported to Moderna’s local distributor, Takeda Pharmaceutical on August 16. That led to the discovery of 39 vials containing foreign material, all from the same lot of 57,000, or about 570,000 doses.
On August 26, Japan said that, as a precaution, it had halted use of 1.63-million Moderna doses shipped to 863 vaccination centres nationwide. It suspended the use of lot 3004667 that included those vials and two similarly sized lots — 3004734 and 3004956.
On Sunday, a vaccination centre in Okinawa prefecture reported finding contaminants from a fourth lot, 3005293. Black substances were spotted in syringes and a vial, with pink substances found in another syringe, the health ministry said. A vaccine centre in Gunma prefecture near Tokyo found a tiny, black substance in a vial from lot 3005236.
Regional authorities temporarily halted use of the affected lots from Okinawa and Gunma. Later, the health ministry and Takeda said there were no safety concerns and no suspension of use was necessary.
The Okinawa cases were probably caused by needles being incorrectly inserted into vials, breaking off bits of the rubber stopper, health minister Norihisa Tamura told reporters on Tuesday.
What are the contaminants?
The contaminants that triggered suspensions of the first three lots are believed to be metallic particles, public broadcaster NHK said, citing health ministry sources.
The ministry has not officially identified the particles, pending an investigation by Takeda, Moderna and its Spanish contract manufacturing partner Rovi. The firms have also yet to comment on what the foreign material is.
Is there a safety issue?
Japan and Moderna have said no safety issues were identified.
Two men, aged 38 and 30, died this month within days of receiving their second Moderna doses, the health ministry said on Saturday. Each had a dose from one of the suspended lots, 3004734. The causes of death are being investigated.
Each had a fever the day after his second dose and died two days after getting the fever. There has been no evidence of contaminants in their shots, a health ministry official told reporters.
By August 8, 991 people had died in Japan after receiving Covid-19 shots from Pfizer/BioNTech, and 11 after receiving Moderna’s. No causality has been established between the injections and deaths, according to the health ministry.
About 500,000 people have had shots from the first three suspended batches, Taro Kono, the minister in charge of the vaccine push, told reporters on Friday.
Are other countries also affected?
Rovi, which packages Moderna vaccines for markets other than the US, said last week the batch in question was meant for distribution only in Japan.
South Korea, which also receives the Moderna vaccines produced from sites in the US and Spain, said it was not affected.
Last week, the EU drugs regulator said it was investigating the incident but an initial assessment yielded no reason to seek a temporary suspension of production.
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
Japan’s contaminated Moderna vaccines: what we know
Tokyo — Japan’s Covid-19 vaccination push suffered a blow from widening reports of contamination in supplies of American pharmaceutical and biotechnology company Moderna’s vaccine. Here are key aspects of the concerns.
When was it first reported and how has it widened?
The first contamination was reported to Moderna’s local distributor, Takeda Pharmaceutical on August 16. That led to the discovery of 39 vials containing foreign material, all from the same lot of 57,000, or about 570,000 doses.
On August 26, Japan said that, as a precaution, it had halted use of 1.63-million Moderna doses shipped to 863 vaccination centres nationwide. It suspended the use of lot 3004667 that included those vials and two similarly sized lots — 3004734 and 3004956.
On Sunday, a vaccination centre in Okinawa prefecture reported finding contaminants from a fourth lot, 3005293. Black substances were spotted in syringes and a vial, with pink substances found in another syringe, the health ministry said. A vaccine centre in Gunma prefecture near Tokyo found a tiny, black substance in a vial from lot 3005236.
Regional authorities temporarily halted use of the affected lots from Okinawa and Gunma. Later, the health ministry and Takeda said there were no safety concerns and no suspension of use was necessary.
The Okinawa cases were probably caused by needles being incorrectly inserted into vials, breaking off bits of the rubber stopper, health minister Norihisa Tamura told reporters on Tuesday.
What are the contaminants?
The contaminants that triggered suspensions of the first three lots are believed to be metallic particles, public broadcaster NHK said, citing health ministry sources.
The ministry has not officially identified the particles, pending an investigation by Takeda, Moderna and its Spanish contract manufacturing partner Rovi. The firms have also yet to comment on what the foreign material is.
Is there a safety issue?
Japan and Moderna have said no safety issues were identified.
Two men, aged 38 and 30, died this month within days of receiving their second Moderna doses, the health ministry said on Saturday. Each had a dose from one of the suspended lots, 3004734. The causes of death are being investigated.
Each had a fever the day after his second dose and died two days after getting the fever. There has been no evidence of contaminants in their shots, a health ministry official told reporters.
By August 8, 991 people had died in Japan after receiving Covid-19 shots from Pfizer/BioNTech, and 11 after receiving Moderna’s. No causality has been established between the injections and deaths, according to the health ministry.
About 500,000 people have had shots from the first three suspended batches, Taro Kono, the minister in charge of the vaccine push, told reporters on Friday.
Are other countries also affected?
Rovi, which packages Moderna vaccines for markets other than the US, said last week the batch in question was meant for distribution only in Japan.
South Korea, which also receives the Moderna vaccines produced from sites in the US and Spain, said it was not affected.
Last week, the EU drugs regulator said it was investigating the incident but an initial assessment yielded no reason to seek a temporary suspension of production.
Reuters
Japan halts use of Moderna vaccine
MOHAMMED NALLA: mRNA is no one-trick pony
The safety of diversification
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.
Most Read
Related Articles
Vaccine booster after six months provides stronger protection, says J&J
Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine gets landmark full approval from FDA
Why herd immunity may remain out of reach worldwide
Published by Arena Holdings and distributed with the Financial Mail on the last Thursday of every month except December and January.