China lays into NBA, comparing tweet about Hong Kong to 9/11
Some Chinese fans have asked for streaming subscription refunds from Tencent, which halted broadcast of Rockets games
09 October 2019 - 12:31
byDavid Stanway and Xihao Jiang
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
A worker removes a promotional banner for the NBA October 10 pre-season game in China between the Brooklyn Nets and the Los Angeles Lakers in Shanghai on October 9 2019. Picture: AFP/HECTOR RETAMAL
Shanghai — On Wednesday, Chinese organisers canceled a fan event on the eve of an National Basketball Association (NBA) exhibition game in Shanghai, the latest fallout in a row over comments by a team official supporting protests in Hong Kong.
Chinese sponsors and partners have been cutting ties with the NBA after a tweet by Houston Rockets GM Daryl Morey last week supporting anti-government protests in the Chinese-ruled city.
The Shanghai Sports Federation said the cancellation of the fan event ahead of Thursday’s game between the Brooklyn Nets and Los Angeles Lakers was due to the “inappropriate attitude” of Morey and NBA commissioner Adam Silver.
A Wednesday afternoon press conference with both teams was indefinitely delayed, organisers said. Outside the team hotel, workers tore down massive banners advertising the game, according to a Reuters witness.
The basketball furore also comes against the backdrop of the US-China trade war, which escalated after Washington imposed visa restrictions on Chinese officials on Tuesday
Silver said on Tuesday that the league supported Morey’s right to exercise his freedom of expression, further angering authorities and some fans in China and threatening the NBA’s business there, said to be worth more than $4bn.
Morey deleted the tweet and apologised on Monday, but Chinese broadcasters, sportswear companies and sponsors have said they are reviewing their ties with the NBA, which has had a presence in China since 1992. The NBA initially described the anger over Morey’s post as “regrettable,” drawing criticism from US politicians, who accused the league of putting its China business ahead of free speech.
Silver, speaking on Tuesday in Japan before a pre-season game between the Rockets and Toronto Raptors, said it was not up to the league to regulate what players, employees and team owners said.
On Wednesday, an editorial in the official English-language China Daily accused Silver of “brazenly endorsing Morey’s secessionist-supporting tweet” and giving “a shot to the arms of the rioters of Hong Kong”.
“If Silver thinks endorsing the indiscriminate violence the radical Hong Kong protesters are resorting to ... is supporting freedom of expression, then he should think again,” it said. The protests are “a bid to liberate the city” and “a secessionist pipe dream” peddled by demonstrators “to justify their summer hooliganism”, the newspaper added.
The protests were initially sparked by opposition to a bill allowing extradition to mainland China, but have since evolved into broader calls for democracy. None of the protesters’ five demands is secession or independence.
The basketball furore also comes against the backdrop of the US-China trade war, which escalated after Washington imposed visa restrictions on Chinese officials on Tuesday.
The Global Times, a Chinese tabloid published by the ruling Communist Party’s People’s Daily newspaper, accused Silver of caving in to political pressure, saying the NBA was treating the Chinese market with arrogant disregard. “Tweeting something offensive to the Chinese people before a series of NBA promotional activities in China only shows a lack of intellect, respect, and responsibility,” it said.
In a separate report, the newspaper also said that some Chinese internet users had made “disrespectful comments” about the September 11 2001, attacks on the World Trade Centre in New York and the Pentagon in Washington, DC. “[It] should remind Western media that for Chinese people, the Hong Kong riots are just like the 9/11, which is horrible and can’t be justified,” the Global Times said.
No-one has been killed in several months of protests in Hong Kong, although scores — mostly protesters and journalists — have been hurt. The 9/11 attacks killed 2,996 people and led to the US invasion of Afghanistan.
Fallout
Basketball is the most popular sport in China, with about 500-million people consuming NBA content. The league has deals with TV and digital media outlets across the country, and teams have played exhibition games annually since 2014. NBA China, launched in 2008 to run the league’s business, is now worth more than $4bn, according to Forbes.
The NBA had planned media events in Shanghai this week ahead of the Nets-Lakers game, but Chinese organisers cancelled an event at a Shanghai school on Tuesday and an open training session with the Nets on Wednesday. Chinese celebrities had already said they would boycott the “fans’ night” before it was cancelled.
State television dropped plans to air NBA exhibition games in China this week, saying a country’s sovereignty and social stability were “not within the scope of freedom of speech”. China has accused the West of stirring up anti-Beijing sentiment in Hong Kong.
Some Chinese fans have asked for streaming subscription refunds from exclusive service provider Tencent, which halted broadcast of Rockets games after the Morey tweet.
Tencent isn’t the only company distancing itself from business dealings with the NBA. Online travel agency Ctrip said on Tuesday it had stopped selling tickets to NBA games and NBA-related tour packages. Smartphone maker Vivo and sportswear maker ANTA Sports Products have also stopped working with the NBA.
However, the escalating row did not seem to bother some waiting outside Shanghai’s Ritz Carlton hotel to catch a glimpse of the NBA players. “Personal opinions belong to them. It doesn’t affect us chasing the stars,” Xu Ziyang, a university student from Jiangsu, told Reuters.
What the Chinese fans say
Yu Jie, fan waiting to see NBA players in Shanghai: “I don’t know why political conflicts affect sporting events. Just because they don’t want us to see Morey’s comments on TV, the fans’ night has been cancelled. I’m patriotic of course. I support that Hong Kong is part of China, but I just don’t understand this.”
Xu Ziyang, another fan outside the players’ hotel: “Personal opinions belong to them. It doesn’t affect us chasing the stars. We don’t know if the players will come out, but they should appear at night to eat dinner or go shopping. The fans’ night has been canceled — that can’t be helped — but I think they will appear.”
Kieth Yuen, NBA basketball fan in Hong Kong: “I don’t think [Silver] is mixing up sports and politics. I think he was speaking as a US citizen on this occasion. I’m really grateful for his support and the support of the majority of the US citizens.”
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
China lays into NBA, comparing tweet about Hong Kong to 9/11
Some Chinese fans have asked for streaming subscription refunds from Tencent, which halted broadcast of Rockets games
Shanghai — On Wednesday, Chinese organisers canceled a fan event on the eve of an National Basketball Association (NBA) exhibition game in Shanghai, the latest fallout in a row over comments by a team official supporting protests in Hong Kong.
Chinese sponsors and partners have been cutting ties with the NBA after a tweet by Houston Rockets GM Daryl Morey last week supporting anti-government protests in the Chinese-ruled city.
The Shanghai Sports Federation said the cancellation of the fan event ahead of Thursday’s game between the Brooklyn Nets and Los Angeles Lakers was due to the “inappropriate attitude” of Morey and NBA commissioner Adam Silver.
A Wednesday afternoon press conference with both teams was indefinitely delayed, organisers said. Outside the team hotel, workers tore down massive banners advertising the game, according to a Reuters witness.
Silver said on Tuesday that the league supported Morey’s right to exercise his freedom of expression, further angering authorities and some fans in China and threatening the NBA’s business there, said to be worth more than $4bn.
Morey deleted the tweet and apologised on Monday, but Chinese broadcasters, sportswear companies and sponsors have said they are reviewing their ties with the NBA, which has had a presence in China since 1992. The NBA initially described the anger over Morey’s post as “regrettable,” drawing criticism from US politicians, who accused the league of putting its China business ahead of free speech.
Silver, speaking on Tuesday in Japan before a pre-season game between the Rockets and Toronto Raptors, said it was not up to the league to regulate what players, employees and team owners said.
On Wednesday, an editorial in the official English-language China Daily accused Silver of “brazenly endorsing Morey’s secessionist-supporting tweet” and giving “a shot to the arms of the rioters of Hong Kong”.
“If Silver thinks endorsing the indiscriminate violence the radical Hong Kong protesters are resorting to ... is supporting freedom of expression, then he should think again,” it said. The protests are “a bid to liberate the city” and “a secessionist pipe dream” peddled by demonstrators “to justify their summer hooliganism”, the newspaper added.
The protests were initially sparked by opposition to a bill allowing extradition to mainland China, but have since evolved into broader calls for democracy. None of the protesters’ five demands is secession or independence.
The basketball furore also comes against the backdrop of the US-China trade war, which escalated after Washington imposed visa restrictions on Chinese officials on Tuesday.
The Global Times, a Chinese tabloid published by the ruling Communist Party’s People’s Daily newspaper, accused Silver of caving in to political pressure, saying the NBA was treating the Chinese market with arrogant disregard. “Tweeting something offensive to the Chinese people before a series of NBA promotional activities in China only shows a lack of intellect, respect, and responsibility,” it said.
In a separate report, the newspaper also said that some Chinese internet users had made “disrespectful comments” about the September 11 2001, attacks on the World Trade Centre in New York and the Pentagon in Washington, DC. “[It] should remind Western media that for Chinese people, the Hong Kong riots are just like the 9/11, which is horrible and can’t be justified,” the Global Times said.
No-one has been killed in several months of protests in Hong Kong, although scores — mostly protesters and journalists — have been hurt. The 9/11 attacks killed 2,996 people and led to the US invasion of Afghanistan.
Fallout
Basketball is the most popular sport in China, with about 500-million people consuming NBA content. The league has deals with TV and digital media outlets across the country, and teams have played exhibition games annually since 2014. NBA China, launched in 2008 to run the league’s business, is now worth more than $4bn, according to Forbes.
The NBA had planned media events in Shanghai this week ahead of the Nets-Lakers game, but Chinese organisers cancelled an event at a Shanghai school on Tuesday and an open training session with the Nets on Wednesday. Chinese celebrities had already said they would boycott the “fans’ night” before it was cancelled.
State television dropped plans to air NBA exhibition games in China this week, saying a country’s sovereignty and social stability were “not within the scope of freedom of speech”. China has accused the West of stirring up anti-Beijing sentiment in Hong Kong.
Some Chinese fans have asked for streaming subscription refunds from exclusive service provider Tencent, which halted broadcast of Rockets games after the Morey tweet.
Tencent isn’t the only company distancing itself from business dealings with the NBA. Online travel agency Ctrip said on Tuesday it had stopped selling tickets to NBA games and NBA-related tour packages. Smartphone maker Vivo and sportswear maker ANTA Sports Products have also stopped working with the NBA.
However, the escalating row did not seem to bother some waiting outside Shanghai’s Ritz Carlton hotel to catch a glimpse of the NBA players. “Personal opinions belong to them. It doesn’t affect us chasing the stars,” Xu Ziyang, a university student from Jiangsu, told Reuters.
What the Chinese fans say
Yu Jie, fan waiting to see NBA players in Shanghai: “I don’t know why political conflicts affect sporting events. Just because they don’t want us to see Morey’s comments on TV, the fans’ night has been cancelled. I’m patriotic of course. I support that Hong Kong is part of China, but I just don’t understand this.”
Xu Ziyang, another fan outside the players’ hotel: “Personal opinions belong to them. It doesn’t affect us chasing the stars. We don’t know if the players will come out, but they should appear at night to eat dinner or go shopping. The fans’ night has been canceled — that can’t be helped — but I think they will appear.”
Kieth Yuen, NBA basketball fan in Hong Kong: “I don’t think [Silver] is mixing up sports and politics. I think he was speaking as a US citizen on this occasion. I’m really grateful for his support and the support of the majority of the US citizens.”
Reuters
Protester crowds swamp Hong Kong court to support jailed activist
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.
Most Read
Published by Arena Holdings and distributed with the Financial Mail on the last Thursday of every month except December and January.