Redistricting set to be the big national battle in the US in 2021
The once-a-decade redrawing of electoral maps can determine which party controls Congress
New York — With the rancorous 2020 US election over, Democrats and Republicans are girding for another national political battle with enormous stakes: redistricting.
The once-a-decade process of redrawing electoral maps can determine which party controls Congress. Though Democrats hold power in Washington, Republicans have the redistricting advantage heading into 2021.
Redistricting occurs every 10 years after the US Census completes its decennial count of the national population.
Because the number of US House of Representatives seats allocated to each state is driven largely by population, states whose population declined are likely to lose seats to others that have seen growth. This year, Texas and Florida are among the states expected to gain seats, while New York, Ohio and Pennsylvania are among those that are likely to lose seats.
Each state uses the census data to draw congressional districts, as well as new state legislative districts. In most states, the legislature produces the maps, with the governor often having veto power. Legislators often try to draw lines in a manner most favourable to their party, a process known as gerrymandering.
This occurs when district lines are deliberately manipulated to benefit one party over another. Federal law prohibits racial gerrymandering, in which minority communities are intentionally disadvantaged, but partisan gerrymandering, in which lines are altered based on how residents have voted, is permitted.
The US Supreme Court ruled in 2019 that federal judges have no jurisdiction over partisan gerrymandering, though the decision does not prevent state courts from weighing in. Both the Pennsylvania and North Carolina state supreme courts have found extreme partisan gerrymandering violates their state constitutions.
Federal law prohibits racial gerrymandering, in which minority communities are intentionally disadvantaged, but partisan gerrymandering, in which lines are altered based on how residents have voted, is permitted.
In general, the most aggressive gerrymanders are seen in Republican-controlled states, thanks to the party’s huge victories in state-level elections in 2010. That has allowed Republicans in Wisconsin, for example, to maintain an iron grip on the legislature, even as Democrats have won statewide races.
After Democrats failed to make big gains in November at the statehouse level, Republicans will have sole power to draw the lines for 181 seats in the 435-seat US House, compared with 49 for Democrats, according to an analysis by the Brennan Center at New York University.
Some experts say Republicans could use redistricting alone to flip the half a dozen House seats needed to regain control of the chamber from Democrats in the 2022 congressional elections.
The biggest immediate concern is a months-long delay in the release of census data due to the coronavirus pandemic. Last week officials said states will not receive detailed figures until September.
As a result, the two states that hold legislative elections in 2021, Virginia and New Jersey, will use their old maps. Meanwhile, about half of US states have legal deadlines calling for new maps to be completed in 2021, which could be impossible given the delay; experts say many states are likely to ask courts for extensions.
Some good-government groups are worried the delay could lead to more extreme gerrymandering, since it would leave little time for any legal challenges to make their way through the courts before the 2022 elections in November.
The Supreme Court’s decision in 2013 to eliminate a section of the Voting Rights Act will also make it more difficult for civil rights groups to prevent gerrymandering. In years past, states with a history of racial discrimination in elections were required to get “preclearance” from the federal government before making any changes to voting laws, but the court struck down that provision.
Another difference this year: voters in several states, including Colorado, Michigan, New York and Virginia, approved the creation of redistricting commissions designed to lessen partisanship, though they have varying degrees of autonomy.
Those ballot initiatives reflect a growing public awareness of redistricting, as reform groups, particularly on the left, have spent years mobilising grassroots efforts in response to Republican gerrymandering in 2011. The backroom deals that marked redistricting a decade ago may be harder to effectuate in 2021.
“Up until recently, redistricting has been obscure, but also obscured — intentionally so,” said Kathay Feng, national redistricting director for the good-government group Common Cause. “That curtain is coming down.”
The biggest fights could emerge in four populous Southern states where Republican control over redistricting could yield big gains in Congress — Texas, Florida, Georgia and North Carolina.
Texas and Florida could pick up a combined five new seats in the US Congress thanks to population growth, while Republicans in Georgia may pursue an aggressive gerrymander in response to surprise statewide wins for Democrats in the presidential and twin Senate runoff elections.
A number of battleground states where Republicans previously enjoyed strong gerrymanders now have Democratic governors or independent commissions, such as Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania.
Several states where one party controls the legislature could also undergo gerrymandering efforts, including Illinois and Maryland for Democrats, and Kansas and Kentucky for Republicans.
Would you like to comment on this article or view other readers' comments?
Register (it’s quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.