US legislators condemn Trump’s tone-deaf ‘lynching’ comment
Apology demanded from president for reference to dangerous and dark chapter of American history
Washington — US President Donald Trump on Tuesday again waded into fraught US racial history by labelling the impeachment inquiry against him a “lynching” — language that conjured memories of decades of killings of thousands of black people — drawing swift bipartisan condemnation.
“All Republicans must remember what they are witnessing here — a lynching. But we will WIN!” Trump wrote on Twitter, referring to the impeachment inquiry in the Democratic-led House of Representatives focusing on his request that Ukraine investigate a domestic political rival, Democrat Joe Biden.
Lynching refers to the murder of thousands of Americans, most of them black, between the 1880s and 1960s, as African-Americans struggled for their rights as US citizens in the aftermath of the Civil War in which Southern states fought in vain to maintain black slavery.
“The president should not compare a constitutionally mandated impeachment inquiry to such a dangerous and dark chapter of American history. It’s irresponsible for him to do so, and I hope that he will apologise,” said House Democratic caucus chairman Hakeem Jeffries, who is black.
Senate majority leader Mitch McConnell, a Republican, said, “Given the history in our country, I would not compare this to a lynching. That was an unfortunate choice of words.” McConnell added that he viewed the House inquiry as “an unfair process” that is denying Trump “procedural safeguards”.
Democrats and other critics have previously accused Trump of stoking racial divisions while trying to appeal to his largely white core of conservative Republican voters, noting his comment in 2017 that there were “very fine people on both sides” at a rally by white nationalists in Charlottesville, Virginia in which a counter-protester was killed.
Some Republican allies agreed with Trump’s use of the word lynching.
“It shows a lot of things about our national media. When it’s about Trump, who cares about the process, as long as you get him. So, yeah, this is a lynching in every sense. This is un-American,” Republican senator Lindsey Graham, whose home state of South Carolina has a large black population, told reporters.
Trump has a long and controversial history on race including decades-old allegations of discrimination in his family’s real estate business. He also championed the death penalty for five black and Latino teens wrongly accused of raping a white woman in 1989 in New York’s Central Park, used an expletive to describe African countries in 2018, and singled out black athletes for criticism after they failed to stand for the national anthem while protesting against racial inequity.
Trump’s lynching comment was immediately condemned by critics as unbecoming of a president.
“For him to say something like that was disgusting, reflects his insensitivity toward the historical tragedies of this country,” said representative Barbara Lee, who added she was not surprised or shocked by Trump's comments but “just very, very disappointed”.
“For Trump to characterise a legal impeachment inquiry as a lynching shows a complete disrespect for the thousands of Black people lynched — murdered — throughout our nation’s history in acts of racism and hatred,” said Karen Baynes-Dunning, interim president of the Southern Poverty Law Center, which advocates for equal opportunity and fights bigotry.
The impeachment inquiry is focused on Trump’s request during a July 25 phone call with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy that he investigate a domestic political rival, former vice-president Joe Biden. Biden is a leading contender to become the Democratic 2020 presidential nominee to run against Trump.
Biden said on Twitter that Trump’s use of the word was “abhorrent” and “despicable”.
Biden, however, said in 1998 the impeachment of President Bill Clinton could be seen as a “partisan lynching”. Biden apologised in a tweet late on Tuesday, saying it “wasn’t the right word to use and I’m sorry about that.”
Senator Tim Scott, the only black Republican US senator and one of just two black Republicans in Congress, said of Trump’s comment, “I get his absolute rejection of the process”, but added he would not use the word lynching. Scott, like Graham, represents South Carolina.
Republican Jeb Bush, a former Florida governor who ran in the partys 2016 presidential nomination contest won by Trump, wrote on Twitter: “The President is not a victim. He should be the most powerful person on the planet. To equate his plight to lynching is grotesque.”
Senator Elizabeth Warren, a leading Democratic presidential candidate, wrote on Twitter, “Lynching is a horrific stain on our country’s history, and it is beyond disgraceful for Donald Trump to invoke one to avoid being held accountable for his crimes.”
White House spokesman Hogan Gidley defended Trump.
“The president was clearly articulating the way he feels and the way you guys have treated him from day one, Gidley told reporters.