Villagers accuse Lesotho Highlands Development Authority of paying a pittance for land
Agency says dispute is about whether owners will be paid a lump sum or annual compensation for decades
In a mountain meadow in northeastern Lesotho Matholang Hlaha sits on a veranda and displays a check for the equivalent of $1.60 (about R28).
That is what she says she got when the Lesotho Highlands Development Authority (LHDA) took away part of her yard in the village of Ha Ramonakalali.
The state agency is laying down roads to build a dam and on June 4 said it had begun tunnel excavations, the latest step in a multibillion-dollar project to funnel water north to ward off a looming crisis in SA.
“You see this check? I will not cash it,” the 68-year-old said as she explained that the documents she received show she will receive no more money. “How would I get to town to cash it? I use public transport” that would cost almost four times more, she said.
Hlaha’s plight is echoed by residents of several villages close to the site of the planned Polihali Dam. Mapuso Lengoasa, 64, was paid 2,114 maloti (R2 108,74) for a field from which she used to earn 15,000 maloti a year by growing sorghum at the base of the Thaba-Sephara mountain. Another resident of Ha Ramonakalali, Maponts’o Keqe, 68, says she was paid 50 maloti for her plot.
Their stories speak to an underfunded compensation programme that threatens to push thousands of people off their land in one of the world’s poorest nations. It’s also SA’s answer to dwindling water sources as climate change worsens drought in Africa’s most-industrialised economy.
The Lesotho company denies it’s underpaying for the land and says it has consulted widely with communities affected.
Polihali, already five years behind schedule, is a crucial part of the 31-billion maloti second stage of a project that dates back to a treaty signed in 1986.
The Lesotho Highlands Water Project helps supply about 20-million people in an area of SA that accounts for half of its GDP and includes its biggest city, Johannesburg, its capital, Pretoria, and key chemical and power plants.
Gauteng is at risk of running short of water within a decade. Cape Town came within weeks of its taps running dry two years ago after the worst dry spell in more than a century.
“You cannot afford for a city like Johannesburg or Gauteng province to run out of water just because there is a drought,” said Mike Muller, a former director-general of SA’s department of water & sanitation and an adviser to water minister Lindiwe Sisulu.
“SA and Lesotho decided that Polihali was the next best step — cheapest and best for the whole region,” Muller said.
When completed in 2026, stage 2 will boost annual water supply to SA to 1.27-billion cubic metres from its current 780-million cubic metres.
The project is also important for Lesotho, a country of about 2-million people that relies on wool, mohair and customs income for much of its revenue. Royalties paid for the transport of the water account for about 2.6% of GDP, according to the government.
But, there is a human cost. Amnesty International says almost 8,000 people are at risk of losing their homes or livelihoods as preparations for the construction of the Polihali Dam begins.
SA “also has an obligation to ensure that the project complies with human rights”, Deprose Muchena, Amnesty’s director for East and Southern Africa, said in a report earlier this year.
SA’s department of human settlements, water & sanitation didn’t respond to a request for comment.
LHDA CEO Tente Tente said while 2,300 households will be affected, only several hundred families will be physically relocated. The agency denied that it’s paying inadequate compensation, saying the main dispute is about whether villagers will be paid a lump sum or annual compensation for decades.
“In the last 1½ years, LHDA has been consulting intensively with households that will be relocated on the selection and layout of relocation sites and the design of the replacement housing,” he said.
The villagers tell a different story.
“What LHDA is doing to us is so painful because this money is so little that it does not help us in any way,” said Leeto Polihali, a member of the Polihali community liaison committee, in an interview from the northern Lesotho district of Mokhotlong. “Everybody knows our concerns.”