Zimbabwe faces trust deficit as it introduces new currency
Analysts say one way to solve the problem is for the government to mend fences with the opposition MDC
Harare — Zimbabwe’s government has a trust problem as it introduces a discounted currency in a bid to reverse chronic cash shortages that left people struggling to access basic goods.
Business people and economists welcomed last week’s decision to abandon an unrealistic dollar peg for the country’s surrogate bond notes and electronic dollars, which were merged into a new currency called the Real Time Gross Settlement (RTGS) dollar. But they expressed doubts about whether the government has the fiscal and monetary discipline to stick to its commitment to lower the budget deficit and keep inflation in check.
“There is nothing to stop Zimbabwe printing money with this new currency,” said Jee-A van der Linde, an analyst at SA-based NKC African Economics.
“The government has basically kicked the can down the road in recent years by trying to stimulate the economy through excessive spending.”
Zimbabwe’s currency woes have undermined President Emmerson Mnangagwa’s efforts to win back foreign investors who were sidelined under his ousted predecessor, Robert Mugabe.
The last time Zimbabwe had its own currency, a decade ago, Mugabe’s government was able to turn on the printing presses to fund higher salaries for government workers, curry favour with the military and pay political opponents, with disastrous economic consequences.
Harare residents now wait outside banks for hours to withdraw a maximum of about $30 in surrogate money or collect remittances from relatives abroad. Snaking queues have become the norm at petrol stations because of a shortage of fuel. Finance minister Mthuli Ncube last week pledged to contain public spending and reiterated the importance of the independence of the central bank.
Yet, investors and Zimbabweans remain concerned that should Mnangagwa’s government come under political or military pressure it may revert to the tricks of the past. Some also fear that the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe will be unwilling to loosen its grip over the currency as its governor, John Mangudya, is thought to oppose the move to abandon the dollar peg.
“It’s quite clear that the minister of finance wants a liberalised currency regime, whereas the governor of the reserve bank doesn’t,” said Eddie Cross, a Zimbabwean economist and former opposition legislator.
Whether Zimbabwean policymakers can convince their doubters, both in financial markets and on the streets, will be central to the success or failure of the new RTGS dollar. If Zimbabweans begin to use banks instead of the black market to exchange any US banknotes they have stashed under their mattresses, then the government could start to rebuild its foreign currency reserves by buying those dollars from banks. That could give it the wherewithal to relaunch the Zimbabwean dollar when the economy has turned a corner.
Zimbabwe ditched its own currency for the US dollar and other currencies in 2009, after hyperinflation reached 500-billion percent the previous year.
But as a chronic hard currency shortage worsened, it introduced a parallel system of bond notes and electronic dollars, nicknamed “zollars”. The substitute currencies were pegged at 1:1 to the US dollar but traded at a discount on the black market. A key test for the RTGS dollar was on Monday, when many Zimbabwean banks started buying and selling RTGS dollars on the interbank market for the first time.
Some large firms will also be able to buy foreign currency from banks, but it is not clear how much or on what terms. Many Zimbabweans are sceptical that the latest monetary intervention will reverse the crisis.
“The government has changed things over and over again,” said Godfrey Chinani, who is worried that customers will no longer be able to afford the car parts he sells from a cramped shop in downtown Harare. He wishes Zimbabwe had switched to the rand instead, as he buys his goods mainly from SA. “People get RTGS as salaries, but when you convert it to rand or US dollars it is worth nothing,” he said. “It won’t work.”
The central bank sold US dollars to a handful of banks at about 2.5 RTGS dollars on Friday, an effective devaluation of 60%.
More than $5m changed hands on the interbank market, a senior reserve bank official told The Standard newspaper. In the coming weeks, the new currency is expected to weaken towards 3.5 to the dollar, the level at which bond notes have been trading on the black market.
Many Zimbabweans fear a return to the hyperinflation era that prevailed during part of Mugabe’s tenure if the RTGS dollar sinks much beyond that point. Inflation already hit a 10-year high of 57% in January, and some public servants say the currency devaluation means the government should raise their salaries by several times.
Authorities have pledged to control the currency’s slide as part of a “managed float”, but how they intend to do that remains a mystery. The central bank said last week it had secured “sufficient lines of credit” to launch the RTGS.
Analysts are scratching their heads as to where the money could have come from. “People are bound to ask what backs this new currency,” said Van der Linde. “It’s no wonder people are distrustful.”
Informal currency traders in downtown Harare said they are waiting to see how the new currency trades before they change their rates.
Analysts say one way for Mnangagwa to build confidence in his economic reforms would be to try to mend a deep political rift with the country’s main opposition party, the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC).
Mnangagwa narrowly defeated MDC leader Nelson Chamisa in an election in 2018, which the opposition says was rigged but which Mnangagwa says he won fairly. A violent security crackdown on post-election protests and on demonstrations in January against a major fuel hike has hardened international attitudes towards Mnangagwa’s government and deterred much-needed investment.
“An economic solution on its own, without being backed by a political solution, won’t take us to a sustainable economic development,” said Eldred Masunungure, a politics professor at the University of Zimbabwe. “Mnangagwa has not yet built enough trust to relaunch the Zimbabwean dollar. But he is testing the waters.”