Zimbabwe diamond exports fund spy agency accused of rights abuses, Global Witness says
Harare — Zimbabwe’s government is using money earned from diamond exports to fund its Central Intelligence Organisation (CIO), blamed for a raft of human-rights abuses as it has helped to keep President Robert Mugabe in power since 1980, Global Witness said.
Diamonds dug from the Marange fields in eastern Zimbabwe are channelled through Dubai, India, the Netherlands and SA by a complicated web of cross-owned companies based in places as diverse as Mauritius, Hong Kong and Johannesburg, the London-based group said in a report released on Monday.
The companies have one thing in common: partnerships with businesses owned by the Zimbabwe government or its military. The earnings, says Global Witness, are funnelled back to the CIO and army "off budget". Zimbabwe’s army and the CIO declined to comment. Calls to the mining ministry were not answered.
In 2011, the finance minister at the time Tendai Biti said the government had lost as much as $15bn in revenue as a result of diamond looting, and accused the elite in Mugabe’s Zanu (PF) of "prospering from the stones". At the time, Biti, then a member of the opposition Movement for Democratic Change, was part of a power-sharing agreement.
Two years later, Mugabe himself lamented the loss of $13bn to diamond theft. The country’s GDP is about $16bn, according to the World Bank.
"The future of Zimbabwe’s diamonds now hangs in the balance. Dwindling reserves are demanding greater investment from an industry shaped by state-sponsored looting and short-term thinking," Global Witness said in the report, the first attempt to link a web of companies and individuals who’ve prospered from the Marange fields.
It blames the government, which owns at least 50% of the diamond mining companies in Marange and selected each of its partners. "With billions missing, any heist — it is clear — started closer to home," it says.
With debt of over $10bn and deteriorating infrastructure, diamond wealth could have lifted Zimbabwe from the mire of unemployment, unpaid public service wages and factory closures, Global Witness said in the report.
The "CIO, the military, notorious smugglers and well-heeled political elites all gained control or ownership of companies operating in Zimbabwe’s diamond fields," Global Witness said. "Despite the role the security forces played in subverting Zimbabwe’s democracy and perpetrating serious human rights abuses, Zimbabwean diamonds are traded freely on international markets."
Global Witness identifies Kusena Diamonds, which it says was "set up by the CIO to secure a secret off-the-books source of financing," Anjin Diamonds, Jinan Diamonds, Mbada Diamonds and the Diamond Mining Corp as companies with links to Zimbabwe’s intelligence and military organisations. Officials were said to be unavailable when calls were made to their offices.
Anjin and Jinan have links to state-owned Zimbabwe Defence Industries, a company still under EU and US sanctions. Gems from Marange have been sold in Antwerp, Dubai and at auctions elsewhere, Global Witness said.
Though production from Marange began to slump in 2014, the country was the fourth-largest producer of the precious gems in 2012, after Russia, the Democratic Republic of Congo and Botswana. The Southern African nation remains in the ranks of the top 10 global diamond producers, Global Witness reported.
Zimbabwe’s diamonds, and the wealth accrued from them, disappear in several ways, according to the report. It is likely that smuggling accounts for many unregistered stones, while the underreporting of gems mined is also a cause for concern, it said. Diamonds are also probably undervalued on the books, with profit accruing to shadowy ownership structures.
"Despite the risks, Zimbabwe’s diamonds are sold on international markets with minimal scrutiny," Global Witness said. "Little is done to ensure the proceeds reach the people of Zimbabwe rather than the powerful elites and oppressive security agents intent on gaining what they can."