Take Covid-19 death data from China with a pinch of salt, experts say
China has reported only two Covid-19 deaths since easing restrictions earlier in December
19 December 2022 - 10:12
byJennifer Creery and Jinshan Hong
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
A health worker pushes a patient in a wheelchair at a hospital in Beijing, China, on December 14 2022. Picture: BLOOMBERG
More than a month after China started seeing an exponential surge in Covid-19 cases, the country has only reported two virus deaths, defying the experience of other more vaccinated and better resourced places as they reopened and fuelling suspicion the true scale of fatalities is being hidden.
The swift abandonment of Covid-19-Zero has seen infections explode, especially in Beijing, which has seen shortages of medicine, overwhelmed hospital staff and deserted streets as residents stay home sick or to avoid the virus. That aligns with what other places experienced as they shifted from eliminating Covid-19 to living with it — except for the lack of officially reported deaths.
Over the weekend, China reported its first fatalities since Covid-19-Zero was dismantled earlier in December. In total, the country has declared just 11 Covid-19 deaths among its 1.4-billion people since November 19, which was more than a week after the government’s first tentative steps towards loosening virus policy.
“The very few Covid-19 deaths reported so far are suspiciously low,” said William Schaffner, an infectious disease expert at Vanderbilt University’s medical school in Tennessee. He said a rapid increase in infections is typically followed by a rise in Covid-19-related deaths a week or two later.
“China has undervaccinated its population, particularly older persons,” Schaffner said. “Thus, we continue to interpret data on Covid-19 from China with a grain of salt.”
Reports on the ground suggest Beijing is seeing a wave of fatalities, with crematorium workers and relatives suggesting at least tens of people have died infected with Covid-19. The news of the two most recent deaths were among the top trending topics on China’s Twitter-like Weibo, with more than 200-million views on Monday, and social media users questioned whether there were more fatalities that hadn’t been reported.
That has stoked speculation officials and hospitals may be attributing deaths from the virus to other ailments as outbreaks mushroom, with Caixin reporting that China had narrowed guidelines for what counts as a Covid-19 death. New guidance was issued on December 6 that notes that some patients who were Covid-19-positive died from underlying illness, and medical facilities have 24 hours to ascertain a person’s cause of death, it said, without saying where it got the information. Previously, anyone who died while Covid-19-positive was considered a Covid-19 death.
Picture: BLOOMBERG.
China’s death toll is far lower than more vaccinated countries that went through reopening waves.
When Omicron hit South Korea, the country swiftly reported fatalities and daily deaths climbed to more than six per 1-million people as infections swelled.
Meanwhile, Australia and New Zealand saw deaths pass three per 1-million a day at the peak of outbreaks after they left elimination behind. Even Singapore, which had a well-planned and gradual shift away from quashing all cases, saw a bit more than a month between its first Omicron case and fatality and ultimately experienced an increase in deaths to about two per 1-million daily.
Hong Kong — where Omicron rampaged though the city’s undervaccinated elderly, recording the deadliest outbreak in the world at one point — reported its first fatalities in early February. That was about three weeks from when the city said the virus was spreading locally. More than 10,800 people in the financial hub have died of Covid-19 in 2022, vs China’s official death tally for the whole pandemic of a little over 5,000.
The low fatality rate so far also flies in the face of China’s own experience. Shanghai reported its first Covid-19 deaths in mid-April, less than three weeks into a brutal two-month citywide lockdown and with fewer than 30,000 cases a day. By late-May, when the outbreak had largely abated, more than 580 people had died.
It’s in China’s interests to obscure or downplay the death toll, given the way it’s approached Covid-19 from the time it emerged.
The government has spent most of the past three years casting China’s containment of Covid-19 and low death toll as proof of the superiority of the Communist system. Now, amid the whipsaw pivot, officials are playing down the virus, with one top health adviser saying it could even just be called a “cold”.
Covid-19 policy is inextricably tied to President Xi Jinping, who is looking to cement his power after securing a third term in October and installing a cabal of new leaders.
All the evidence suggests China is headed for a more severe pandemic exit than other former Covid-19-Zero countries.
The elderly are a particular concern. Unlike other countries that prioritised vaccinating residents of aged-care facilities, China’s elderly have proved difficult to persuade and the group remains extremely undervaccinated. Just 40% of people older than 80 years had received a booster by late-November and — while there’s been a recent push to inoculate older people — the figure likely remains low given the lack of mandates, as other countries deployed.
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
Take Covid-19 death data from China with a pinch of salt, experts say
China has reported only two Covid-19 deaths since easing restrictions earlier in December
More than a month after China started seeing an exponential surge in Covid-19 cases, the country has only reported two virus deaths, defying the experience of other more vaccinated and better resourced places as they reopened and fuelling suspicion the true scale of fatalities is being hidden.
The swift abandonment of Covid-19-Zero has seen infections explode, especially in Beijing, which has seen shortages of medicine, overwhelmed hospital staff and deserted streets as residents stay home sick or to avoid the virus. That aligns with what other places experienced as they shifted from eliminating Covid-19 to living with it — except for the lack of officially reported deaths.
Over the weekend, China reported its first fatalities since Covid-19-Zero was dismantled earlier in December. In total, the country has declared just 11 Covid-19 deaths among its 1.4-billion people since November 19, which was more than a week after the government’s first tentative steps towards loosening virus policy.
“The very few Covid-19 deaths reported so far are suspiciously low,” said William Schaffner, an infectious disease expert at Vanderbilt University’s medical school in Tennessee. He said a rapid increase in infections is typically followed by a rise in Covid-19-related deaths a week or two later.
“China has undervaccinated its population, particularly older persons,” Schaffner said. “Thus, we continue to interpret data on Covid-19 from China with a grain of salt.”
Reports on the ground suggest Beijing is seeing a wave of fatalities, with crematorium workers and relatives suggesting at least tens of people have died infected with Covid-19. The news of the two most recent deaths were among the top trending topics on China’s Twitter-like Weibo, with more than 200-million views on Monday, and social media users questioned whether there were more fatalities that hadn’t been reported.
That has stoked speculation officials and hospitals may be attributing deaths from the virus to other ailments as outbreaks mushroom, with Caixin reporting that China had narrowed guidelines for what counts as a Covid-19 death. New guidance was issued on December 6 that notes that some patients who were Covid-19-positive died from underlying illness, and medical facilities have 24 hours to ascertain a person’s cause of death, it said, without saying where it got the information. Previously, anyone who died while Covid-19-positive was considered a Covid-19 death.
China’s death toll is far lower than more vaccinated countries that went through reopening waves.
When Omicron hit South Korea, the country swiftly reported fatalities and daily deaths climbed to more than six per 1-million people as infections swelled.
Meanwhile, Australia and New Zealand saw deaths pass three per 1-million a day at the peak of outbreaks after they left elimination behind. Even Singapore, which had a well-planned and gradual shift away from quashing all cases, saw a bit more than a month between its first Omicron case and fatality and ultimately experienced an increase in deaths to about two per 1-million daily.
Hong Kong — where Omicron rampaged though the city’s undervaccinated elderly, recording the deadliest outbreak in the world at one point — reported its first fatalities in early February. That was about three weeks from when the city said the virus was spreading locally. More than 10,800 people in the financial hub have died of Covid-19 in 2022, vs China’s official death tally for the whole pandemic of a little over 5,000.
The low fatality rate so far also flies in the face of China’s own experience. Shanghai reported its first Covid-19 deaths in mid-April, less than three weeks into a brutal two-month citywide lockdown and with fewer than 30,000 cases a day. By late-May, when the outbreak had largely abated, more than 580 people had died.
It’s in China’s interests to obscure or downplay the death toll, given the way it’s approached Covid-19 from the time it emerged.
The government has spent most of the past three years casting China’s containment of Covid-19 and low death toll as proof of the superiority of the Communist system. Now, amid the whipsaw pivot, officials are playing down the virus, with one top health adviser saying it could even just be called a “cold”.
Covid-19 policy is inextricably tied to President Xi Jinping, who is looking to cement his power after securing a third term in October and installing a cabal of new leaders.
All the evidence suggests China is headed for a more severe pandemic exit than other former Covid-19-Zero countries.
The elderly are a particular concern. Unlike other countries that prioritised vaccinating residents of aged-care facilities, China’s elderly have proved difficult to persuade and the group remains extremely undervaccinated. Just 40% of people older than 80 years had received a booster by late-November and — while there’s been a recent push to inoculate older people — the figure likely remains low given the lack of mandates, as other countries deployed.
More stories like this available at bloomberg.com
Bloomberg
China braces for Covid spread as citizens head to the countryside for holidays
China races to vaccinate vulnerable as Covid-19 infections explode
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.
Most Read
Related Articles
China braces for Covid spread as citizens head to the countryside for holidays
China races to vaccinate vulnerable as Covid-19 infections explode
Published by Arena Holdings and distributed with the Financial Mail on the last Thursday of every month except December and January.