Huawei CFO to try Trump card against US in extradition battle
The president said he would intervene in the US case against CFO Meng Wanzhou if it would help close a trade deal with China
Vancouver/New York — Huawei's chief financial officer intends to seek a stay of extradition proceedings in part based on statements by President Donald Trump about the case, which her lawyers say disqualifies the US from pursuing the matter in Canada.
CFO Meng Wanzhou, 47, the daughter of Huawei Technologies's billionaire founder, Ren Zhengfei, was arrested at Vancouver's airport in December on a US warrant and is fighting extradition on charges that she conspired to defraud global banks about Huawei's relationship with a company operating in Iran.
After the arrest, Trump said he would intervene in the US case against Meng if it would help close a trade deal with China.
Meng's defence lawyers said in a document presented to the British Columbia Supreme Court on Wednesday that they intend to apply for the stay of the extradition proceedings based on abuses that go beyond Trump's comments.
The lawyers also claim Meng was unlawfully detained, searched and interrogated at the airport, with her arrest delayed under the guise of a routine immigration check.
In addition, Meng's counsel argued there is no evidence she misrepresented to a bank Huawei's relationship with a company operating in Iran called Skycom, thereby putting the bank at risk of violating US sanctions law, or that the bank relied on her statements to its detriment.
The lawyers claim the bank understood the relationship between Huawei and Skycom.
A spokesman for HSBC, which has been identified as the bank, declined to comment.
Huawei has previously said Skycom was a local business partner in Iran. The US maintains it was an unofficial subsidiary used to conceal Huawei's Iran business.
Meng defence lawyer, Scott Fenton, told the court that during Meng's three-hour detention at the airport in December, Meng's rights "were placed in total suspension".
Speaking in Beijing on Thursday, Chinese foreign ministry spokesman Geng Shuang again demanded Meng's release and return to China.
"The US and Canada abused their bilateral extradition treaty and took unreasonable compulsory measures against a Chinese citizen, which is a serious violation of the legitimate rights and interests of the Chinese citizen," he said. "This is a serious political incident."
Next court appearance
The lawyers also argue that Meng cannot be extradited because the conduct at issue would not be criminal in Canada.
The bank and wire fraud charges do not meet that criteria because Meng is accused of misrepresenting HSBC to engage in transactions that violate US sanctions laws, the lawyers said. They also note that, under 2019 Canadian sanction law, there would be no risk of fines or forfeiture for any bank in Canada.
"Put another way, the alleged offence could only exist in a country that prohibits international financial transactions in relation to Iran," the lawyers said in court documents. "Canada is no longer such a country."
Meng's lawyers did not say when they would apply for the stay of the extradition hearing, whose date has not been set. She will next appear in court on September 23, when her defence will make more applications for further disclosure surrounding her arrest at the airport. The process could take years.
Meng's case has attracted global attention and sparked a diplomatic crisis between Beijing and Ottawa.
Huawei said on Wednesday that the criminal case against Meng is based on allegations that are simply not true, adding that the US-ordered arrest was "guided by political considerations and tactics, not by the rule of law".
Huawei and Skycom are also defendants in the US case, accused of bank and wire fraud, as well as violating US sanctions on Iran.
Meng was released from jail in December on C$10m bail and must wear an electronic ankle bracelet and pay for security guards. She has been living in a Vancouver home that was valued at C$5m in 2018.
Meng arrived at court on Wednesday wearing an elegant full-length black and gray weave-pattern dress, with the ankle monitor prominently visible.
At the hearing, her lawyers requested she be allowed to move to a second Vancouver mansion, one which has been under renovation and was assessed at C$13m in 2018. Justice Heather J Holmes granted Meng's request to move to the larger home for security reasons.
The relocation is sure to deepen the anger of some Canadians at the difference in her lifestyle and how two Canadians are being held in a Chinese detention centre, said Paul Evans, a professor at the University of British Columbia's School of Public Policy and Global Affairs.
Chinese police detained the two Canadian citizens after Meng's arrest.
In recent weeks, China has raised the pressure on Canada and halted Canadian canola imports and suspended the permits of two major pork producers.