Despite the fear and confusion gripping the country, now is not the time to succumb to despair
18 July 2021 - 17:30
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
The violence of the past week is deplorable, not only in terms of the tragic loss of life, property and vital infrastructure but also because the longer-term economic impact of this destruction will hurt the poor most.
Regardless of the immediate triggers of this violence, these tragic and damaging events undoubtedly have their origin in 12 years of weak economic growth, increased unemployment and growing inequality. This vicious cycle has fuelled a culture of despair in which many in our country, utterly excluded and without any stake in the system, feel they have little to lose.
Despite the fear and confusion gripping the country, now is not the time to succumb to despair, nor to be panicked into making rash decisions that could damage our democracy and collective futures. In fact, now is the time to maintain an even keel as we remain focused on our longer-term goals as a society, a young democracy and a growing economy.
As such, and despite the obvious immediate economic impact of the violence on growth and inflation, I am not changing any of my forecasts just yet. Since current events present definite downside risks to growth, my GDP forecasts may need to be adjusted from 5.5% back down to 5%. Once the violence abates, rebuilding and restocking of ravaged infrastructure and supplies should support a short-term increase in economic activity.
While supply side interruptions may drive inflation in some sectors over the short term, we do not expect this to impact longer-term inflation trajectories. So, while our current 4% CPI average inflation forecast might have to be revised a touch upwards, we will not make any rash decisions. Instead, we will wait and reassess once the situation calms down.
As investment professionals we have a responsibility to look through the noise and emotion, recognising that even in the past few days we have come a long way towards establishing calm and gaining clarity on the drivers of these tragic events. Moreover, the rule of law remains supreme in SA, and other structural positives remain in place. These are not about to disappear overnight. Thus, even though investor confidence will be damaged, our medium-term outlook remains unchanged.
Looking ahead, however, much remains to be done in terms of sustaining and deepening structural policy reforms. We do not believe recent events will derail this plan. In fact, just the opposite. Bold and significant economic reform is the only way to meaningfully address the economic exclusion and alienation behind this tragic and costly violence.
We hope one silver lining to emerge from this tragedy will be a renewed commitment and far greater urgency from the Ramaphosa administration for market and investment-positive reform. This commitment should be coupled with a clear disavowal of the damaging radical economic transformation rhetoric that has not only sown the seeds of the violence but is also largely responsible for the weak growth that has seen so many of our people excluded from our economy.
Johann Els Chief economist, Old Mutual Investment Group
JOIN THE DISCUSSION: Send us an e-mail with your comments. Letters of more than 300 words will be edited for length. Send your letter by e-mail to letters@businesslive.co.za. Anonymous correspondence will not be published. Writers should include a daytime telephone number.
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
LETTER: Focus on long-term goals
Despite the fear and confusion gripping the country, now is not the time to succumb to despair
The violence of the past week is deplorable, not only in terms of the tragic loss of life, property and vital infrastructure but also because the longer-term economic impact of this destruction will hurt the poor most.
Regardless of the immediate triggers of this violence, these tragic and damaging events undoubtedly have their origin in 12 years of weak economic growth, increased unemployment and growing inequality. This vicious cycle has fuelled a culture of despair in which many in our country, utterly excluded and without any stake in the system, feel they have little to lose.
Despite the fear and confusion gripping the country, now is not the time to succumb to despair, nor to be panicked into making rash decisions that could damage our democracy and collective futures. In fact, now is the time to maintain an even keel as we remain focused on our longer-term goals as a society, a young democracy and a growing economy.
As such, and despite the obvious immediate economic impact of the violence on growth and inflation, I am not changing any of my forecasts just yet. Since current events present definite downside risks to growth, my GDP forecasts may need to be adjusted from 5.5% back down to 5%. Once the violence abates, rebuilding and restocking of ravaged infrastructure and supplies should support a short-term increase in economic activity.
While supply side interruptions may drive inflation in some sectors over the short term, we do not expect this to impact longer-term inflation trajectories. So, while our current 4% CPI average inflation forecast might have to be revised a touch upwards, we will not make any rash decisions. Instead, we will wait and reassess once the situation calms down.
As investment professionals we have a responsibility to look through the noise and emotion, recognising that even in the past few days we have come a long way towards establishing calm and gaining clarity on the drivers of these tragic events. Moreover, the rule of law remains supreme in SA, and other structural positives remain in place. These are not about to disappear overnight. Thus, even though investor confidence will be damaged, our medium-term outlook remains unchanged.
Looking ahead, however, much remains to be done in terms of sustaining and deepening structural policy reforms. We do not believe recent events will derail this plan. In fact, just the opposite. Bold and significant economic reform is the only way to meaningfully address the economic exclusion and alienation behind this tragic and costly violence.
We hope one silver lining to emerge from this tragedy will be a renewed commitment and far greater urgency from the Ramaphosa administration for market and investment-positive reform. This commitment should be coupled with a clear disavowal of the damaging radical economic transformation rhetoric that has not only sown the seeds of the violence but is also largely responsible for the weak growth that has seen so many of our people excluded from our economy.
Johann Els
Chief economist, Old Mutual Investment Group
JOIN THE DISCUSSION: Send us an e-mail with your comments. Letters of more than 300 words will be edited for length. Send your letter by e-mail to letters@businesslive.co.za. Anonymous correspondence will not be published. Writers should include a daytime telephone number.
SA social unrest and implications for national security
LETTER: It's in SA’s socio-economic situation we must seek an explanation for this week's events
GARY RYNHART: Tortoise strategy is a better bet than racing ahead to score political wins
WATCH: The devastating impact of riots on SA’s economy
More important than the rule of law: the rule of justice
LETTER: Everyone is running for the hills
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.
Most Read
Related Articles
LETTER: Poultry farm attacks a concern
OLIVER DICKSON: A business community in denial is complicit in Ramaphosa’s ...
MICHAEL MORRIS: Years of high-level theft created tinderbox of desperation
EDITORIAL: Violence exposes a weak state with illusionary power
KHAYA SITHOLE: As social contract falls apart, poor don’t give a hoot about rand
PETER BRUCE: State of emergency is too much — unless your wife has run out of ...
Published by Arena Holdings and distributed with the Financial Mail on the last Thursday of every month except December and January.