The party’s failure to engage the public imagination with its grandiose ‘national shutdown’ is a blow to its leadership
22 March 2023 - 05:00
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
A vehicle featuring a picture of EFF leader Julius Malema behind street vendors during a national protest organised by the EFF, March 20 2023. Picture: GUILLEM SARTORIO/BLOOMBERG
There is a good deal to learn from the EFF’s protest on Monday, which it rather grandiosely branded a “national shutdown”. It was in reality a damp squib. Though the party will undoubtedly deny this and blame external factors for the general lack of support, the party’s failure to engage the public imagination is a blow to the EFF’s leadership.
The EFF threw the kitchen sink at this event. It called for disruption to national key points. It threatened those who wanted to work, and social media was an incoherent mess of melodrama and misinformation.
The EFF shot to prominence on a brand of brownshirt tactics and radical socialism, seeking to capitalise on the frustrations of the poor. Now, though, just as a role in government seems possible, it has been unable to express clearly what it stands for. Nor does it seem able to persuade the poor that it speaks for them.
Perhaps more importantly, the protest taught us about ourselves. There is an obvious fear in SA of a repeat of 2021’s disaster in KwaZulu-Natal, and the EFF managed to spook the country on the basis of that. But it’s an old trick now; South Africans appear more interested in those who offer solutions to our country’s problems. The EFF has some way to go to persuade people that it has any.
The state’s response was strong, showing far better organisation and capacity than SA has seen for some time. We would like to see such a spirited response to our many other crises.
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
EDITORIAL: The EFF’s limits
The party’s failure to engage the public imagination with its grandiose ‘national shutdown’ is a blow to its leadership
There is a good deal to learn from the EFF’s protest on Monday, which it rather grandiosely branded a “national shutdown”. It was in reality a damp squib. Though the party will undoubtedly deny this and blame external factors for the general lack of support, the party’s failure to engage the public imagination is a blow to the EFF’s leadership.
The EFF threw the kitchen sink at this event. It called for disruption to national key points. It threatened those who wanted to work, and social media was an incoherent mess of melodrama and misinformation.
The EFF shot to prominence on a brand of brownshirt tactics and radical socialism, seeking to capitalise on the frustrations of the poor. Now, though, just as a role in government seems possible, it has been unable to express clearly what it stands for. Nor does it seem able to persuade the poor that it speaks for them.
Perhaps more importantly, the protest taught us about ourselves. There is an obvious fear in SA of a repeat of 2021’s disaster in KwaZulu-Natal, and the EFF managed to spook the country on the basis of that. But it’s an old trick now; South Africans appear more interested in those who offer solutions to our country’s problems. The EFF has some way to go to persuade people that it has any.
The state’s response was strong, showing far better organisation and capacity than SA has seen for some time. We would like to see such a spirited response to our many other crises.
EDITORIAL: Wrecking ball EFF hits brick wall of fed-up broad front
EDITORIAL: Stop wasting energy on NHI and fix the rot
EDITORIAL: Bejani Chauke was right to quit
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.
Most Read
Related Articles
EFF protest: Sporadic incidents, orderly marches, and a cordial handshake to ...
JOHN ENDRES: EFF’s mass protest turns out to be a damp squib
EFF protest | The latest developments
EDITORIAL: Wrecking ball EFF hits brick wall of fed-up broad front
Tshwane a ghost town as EFF-led protests in full swing
EFF says state is targeting its leaders to stifle protests
Malema and supporters camp outside Ramaphosa’s official Pretoria residence
National protest: Cele tells police to enforce law but ignore ‘war talk’
Provincial police chief says more than R30m has been spent to keep KZN safe
SA’s busiest courts in virtual shutdown amid EFF protest
Published by Arena Holdings and distributed with the Financial Mail on the last Thursday of every month except December and January.