Another postponement gives Jacob Zuma a birthday away from court and his corruption trial
Pietermaritzburg high court judge Piet Koen indicated during argument he had no real discretion not to agree to Zuma’s application
11 April 2022 - 15:20
by TANIA BROUGHTON
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
State prosecutor Billy Downer, advocate Dali Mpofu and advocate Barry Roux at the Pietermaritzburg high court on Monday. Picture: SANDILE NDLOVU
It was not intentional, but Pietermaritzburg high court judge Piet Koen gave Jacob Zuma an early birthday present by agreeing to postpone the former president’s arms deal corruption trial.
Koen said he had little or no discretion in announcing the postponement to May. SA law dictates that if an appeal has been lodged against a ruling, that ruling is automatically suspended unless it can be shown, in exceptional circumstances, that the appeal is an abuse of court processes.
In this matter, the state had not done enough to prove this.
"Zuma has challenged many decisions, invoking the appeal process to the highest courts, many of them unsuccessful, which have resulted in unfortunate delays," Koen said. "As much as they may be viewed with suspicion and result in delays which favour him, they do not amount to an abuse. The finding of mala fides would require more proof by the state."
Somewhat prophetically, in a 2017 ruling involving the prosecution of Zuma, Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) judges quoted TS Eliot, who spoke of "the recurrent end of the unending".
It was this that lead prosecutor Billy Downer repeated in his argument against the postponement on Monday, submitting that "there was more to come". He said Koen surely had discretion because Zuma was abusing the system through his "Stalingrad defence", which has gone on for two decades.
Zuma’s advocate, Dali Mpofu, labelled this "a gratuitous insult not borne out by the facts".
Former president Jacob Zuma has been granted a postponement of his trial until at least the end of May.
Downer, the subject of Zuma’s present complaints, said that Koen correctly rejected the former president’s bid to oust him as lead prosecutor on the grounds that he had no title to prosecute. While Zuma complains that Downer is biased and has accused him of misconduct, Koen said that he was not entitled to raise these issues during his trial.
He ruled that "title to prosecute", in decided law, had nothing to do with bias or misconduct, but was about legal standing — the authority to prosecute — which Downer has.
Two SCA judges, in considering Zuma’s application for leave to appeal against this ruling, found in March there were no prospects of success.
Zuma’s legal team has now asked SCA president Mandisa Maya to reconsider this decision. Koen said the SCA’s final decision is outstanding. "Regrettably it will result in a further delay, but it is ordained by statute. It is unavoidable," Koen said.
While all eyes are now on Maya, Zuma, who turns 80 on Tuesday and was not present in court on Monday because of a medical emergency, still has a few more legal rabbits to pull out of his hat. Depending on the outcome of the reconsideration application, he can approach the Constitutional Court.
Koen set a holding date of May 17, pending the decision of the SCA, and said if the matter is disposed of by then, the trial will resume on May 31.
The day included some drama when Zuma supporter and former SAA chair Dudu Myeni allegedly tried to assault photographer Sandile Ndlovu when he took pictures of her, Carl Niehaus and Zuma’s daughter Duduzile Zuma-Sambudla.
Zuma and his co-accused, French arms company Thales, face charges of racketeering, corruption, money laundering and fraud relating to the arms deal. The former president is accused of receiving about R4m via his former financial adviser, Schabir Shaik, to assist Thales to secure defence contracts.
Shaik was convicted in 2005, but released on medical parole in 2009.
Support our award-winning journalism. The Premium package (digital only) is R30 for the first month and thereafter you pay R129 p/m now ad-free for all subscribers.
ARMS DEAL
Another postponement gives Jacob Zuma a birthday away from court and his corruption trial
Pietermaritzburg high court judge Piet Koen indicated during argument he had no real discretion not to agree to Zuma’s application
It was not intentional, but Pietermaritzburg high court judge Piet Koen gave Jacob Zuma an early birthday present by agreeing to postpone the former president’s arms deal corruption trial.
Koen said he had little or no discretion in announcing the postponement to May. SA law dictates that if an appeal has been lodged against a ruling, that ruling is automatically suspended unless it can be shown, in exceptional circumstances, that the appeal is an abuse of court processes.
In this matter, the state had not done enough to prove this.
"Zuma has challenged many decisions, invoking the appeal process to the highest courts, many of them unsuccessful, which have resulted in unfortunate delays," Koen said. "As much as they may be viewed with suspicion and result in delays which favour him, they do not amount to an abuse. The finding of mala fides would require more proof by the state."
Somewhat prophetically, in a 2017 ruling involving the prosecution of Zuma, Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) judges quoted TS Eliot, who spoke of "the recurrent end of the unending".
It was this that lead prosecutor Billy Downer repeated in his argument against the postponement on Monday, submitting that "there was more to come". He said Koen surely had discretion because Zuma was abusing the system through his "Stalingrad defence", which has gone on for two decades.
Zuma’s advocate, Dali Mpofu, labelled this "a gratuitous insult not borne out by the facts".
Former president Jacob Zuma has been granted a postponement of his trial until at least the end of May.
Downer, the subject of Zuma’s present complaints, said that Koen correctly rejected the former president’s bid to oust him as lead prosecutor on the grounds that he had no title to prosecute. While Zuma complains that Downer is biased and has accused him of misconduct, Koen said that he was not entitled to raise these issues during his trial.
He ruled that "title to prosecute", in decided law, had nothing to do with bias or misconduct, but was about legal standing — the authority to prosecute — which Downer has.
Two SCA judges, in considering Zuma’s application for leave to appeal against this ruling, found in March there were no prospects of success.
Zuma’s legal team has now asked SCA president Mandisa Maya to reconsider this decision. Koen said the SCA’s final decision is outstanding. "Regrettably it will result in a further delay, but it is ordained by statute. It is unavoidable," Koen said.
While all eyes are now on Maya, Zuma, who turns 80 on Tuesday and was not present in court on Monday because of a medical emergency, still has a few more legal rabbits to pull out of his hat. Depending on the outcome of the reconsideration application, he can approach the Constitutional Court.
Koen set a holding date of May 17, pending the decision of the SCA, and said if the matter is disposed of by then, the trial will resume on May 31.
The day included some drama when Zuma supporter and former SAA chair Dudu Myeni allegedly tried to assault photographer Sandile Ndlovu when he took pictures of her, Carl Niehaus and Zuma’s daughter Duduzile Zuma-Sambudla.
Zuma and his co-accused, French arms company Thales, face charges of racketeering, corruption, money laundering and fraud relating to the arms deal. The former president is accused of receiving about R4m via his former financial adviser, Schabir Shaik, to assist Thales to secure defence contracts.
Shaik was convicted in 2005, but released on medical parole in 2009.
TimesLIVE
Jacob Zuma plans new bid against prosecutor Billy Downer
BUSISIWE MAVUSO: Mogajane’s competence should be the norm in government, not the exception
ANC in eThekwini votes in corruption-accused Zandile Gumede
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.
Most Read
Related Articles
Automotive industry calls for cool heads before Numsa wage talks
LUKANYO MNYANDA: Global trend points to Reserve Bank MPC needing more members
Ramaphosa takes the plunge and ends state of disaster
Published by Arena Holdings and distributed with the Financial Mail on the last Thursday of every month except December and January.