Judge Nugent urges court to dismiss Tom Moyane’s challenge
Judge Robert Nugent says the case is not in the interests of justice
Judge Robert Nugent has urged the Constitutional Court to block suspended SA Revenue Service (Sars) commissioner Tom Moyane’s bid to challenge the fairness of his tax administration inquiry, saying it is not “in the interests of justice” for SA’s highest court to hear the case. In a 700-page application to the apex court, Moyane seeks to challenge the legality of the Nugent commission into governance and tax administration and the Bham inquiry into his fitness to hold office. President Cyril Ramaphosa, who appointed Nugent, and Public Enterprises Minister Pravin Gordhan are also opposing the application, but both have yet to file affidavits detailing the basis of their opposition. Nugent’s application may be the precursor to Moyane’s dismissal. In his interim report to the president, filed late in September, it is understood that Nugent has recommended the immediate removal of Moyane as Sars commissioner. While advocate Azhar Bham, who is chairing the inquiry into Moyane’s fitness t...