Asian shares fall as doubts over US-China truce emerge
Equities lose ground as a relief rally peters out amid rising doubts over whether China and the US will be able to resolve trade differences
Shanghai — Asian shares fell on Tuesday as a relief rally petered out amid rising doubts over whether China and the US will be able to resolve trade differences.
An inverted US yield curve also raised concerns about a possible recession.
MSCI’s broadest index of Asia-Pacific shares outside Japan fell 0.3% as Chinese equity markets struggled to move out of negative territory.
Chinese blue-chip shares in Shenzhen and Shanghai were slightly weaker, and the benchmark Shanghai Composite index edged barely higher. Shares in Hong Kong lost 0.3%.
Australia shares gave up 0.8% and Seoul’s Kospi fell 0.6%, while Japan's Nikkei stock index was 1.3% lower.
The temporary freeze on further hostilities in the trade war between the US and China had sparked a global rally in equity markets on Monday, pushing MSCI’s all-country world index up 1.3%.
But even before the trading day ended, major US indices pulled back from intraday highs as investors pondered unresolved issues between the two countries.
Overnight, the Dow Jones Industrial Average closed 1.13% higher, the S&P 500 gained 1.09% and the Nasdaq Composite added 1.51%.
“Overall trade news overnight [has] probably left the market with more questions than answers, can the US and China really resolve their differences in 90 days?” National Australia Bank analysts said in a note to clients.
“It seems that more details and signs of progress will be needed if the initial trade truce warm fuzzy feeling is to be sustained.”
Already, there was confusion over when the 90-day period would start. A White House official said it started on December 1. Earlier, White House economic adviser Larry Kudlow told reporters it would start on January 1.
Moreover, none of the commitments that US officials said had been given by China, including reducing its 40% tariffs on cars, were agreed to in writing and specifics had yet to be hammered out.
“The fear across global markets is that this is just a short-term relief rally and we will find ourselves back where we were a few weeks ago and staring down the barrel of a long-term global growth slow down,” Nick Twidale, Sydney-based analyst at Rakuten Securities Australia said in a note.
“In the short term it seems we may find investors once again back to trading sentiment fluctuations as news hits the markets piecemeal on trade agreement progress.”
Adding to worry about the outlook for the global economy, the yield curve between US three-year and five-year notes, and between two-year and five-year paper inverted on Monday — the first parts of the treasury yield curve to invert since the financial crisis, excluding very short-dated debt.
Analysts expect an inversion of the two-year, 10-year yield curve — seen as a predictor of a US recession — to follow suit.
On Tuesday, the yield on benchmark 10-year treasury notes fell to 2.9407% compared with its US close of 2.991% on Monday. The two-year yield also fell, but by a narrower margin, touching 2.8028% compared with a US close of 2.833%.
That put the spread between 10-year and two-year treasuries at less than 14 basis points, its flattest level since July 2007.
“The market pricing evident in the yield curve inversion from three to five segment of the curve, as well as the dip in the 10-year yield below 3% yesterday [Monday], goes to reinforce these concerns” about the US economy potentially heading into a recession, said Prakash Sakpal, an economist at ING in Singapore.
However, he added that solid US manufacturing data released Monday pointed to a stronger economic outlook, with new orders a “key driver” in boosting activity.
In contrast to how Asian equity markets could not sustain Monday’s rally, oil prices continued to rise after surging 4% the day before on the US-China trade truce, and ahead of a key Opec meeting expected to lead to supply cuts.
US crude was 1.2% higher at $53.58 a barrel, and Brent crude futures gained 1.1% to $62.35 a barrel.
In the currency market, the dollar index, which tracks the greenback against a basket of peers, softened 0.2% to 96.808.
The dollar was 0.3% weaker against the yen, at ¥113.28, and the euro gained 0.2% to $1.1373.
As the dollar weakened, China’s yuan continued to surge. Since Friday, it has added more than 1,000 pips against the greenback, reaching 6.8545 on Tuesday morning. At 3.27am GMT, it was trading at 6.8613 to the dollar.
Federal Reserve chair Jerome Powell was scheduled to testify on Wednesday to a congressional joint economic committee, but the hearing was postponed because of a national day of mourning for former US president George HW Bush, who died on Friday.
The dollar came under pressure last week on Powell’s comments that rates were nearing neutral levels, which markets widely interpreted as signalling a slowdown in the Fed's rate-hike cycle.
Spot gold jumped on the weaker dollar, trading up 0.40% at $1,235.88/oz.