Euro and Italian bonds sold as EU warns on Italy budget
The EU calls Italy’s draft budget an ‘unprecedented’ breach of EU fiscal rules; world stocks are generally lacklustre
London — Investors sold Italian bonds and the euro on Friday, with Italy’s bond yield hitting four-year highs as the EU called its draft budget an “unprecedented” breach of EU fiscal rules.
Late on Thursday, the European Commission told Rome in a letter that planned government spending was too high and that its structural deficit would rise instead of fall, and that the country’s public debt would not fall in line with EU rules.
Italy’s prime minister Giuseppe Conte defended the budget.
EU authorities will send a formal warning letter that could lead to Brussels rejecting the draft before the end of the month.
While it isn’t unusual for the EU to ask member countries for clarification on points of their budget plans, the sending of a formal letter and the tone of the comments were particularly strong, analysts said. “The letter was more sharply worded than usual. It described the budget as ‘an obvious deviation’ from prior commitments, on an ‘unprecedented’ scale,” Deutsche Bank research strategist Jim Reid said in a note to clients.
Italy’s benchmark 10-year bond yields rose to 3.74% in early trade on Friday, the highest since February 2014.
The closely watched Italian-German bond yield spread hit a fresh five-and-a-half-year high of 332 basis points. Portuguese and Spanish bonds, which have been resilient so far through the Italian budget worries, were also sold, with several analysts suggesting this was the first sign of contagion from Italy.
Italian stocks tumbled nearly 1.2%, while its bank stocks, in particular, fell almost 3%. The news also weighed on the euro, which fell to a two-month low.
Analysts at MUFG said that if Italian government bond (BTP) yields moved notably higher “correlations could well strengthen and this would provide further downside pressure for the euro”.
Investors have been pricing in the possibility that the tussle between Italy and the EU will force the European Central Bank (ECB) to be more cautious in removing stimulus. Eurozone money markets are now not fully pricing in an interest rate rise from the ECB until October 2019. Earlier this week, they were projecting an increase next September.
Stock markets all round were a bit lacklustre: data showing China’s economy growing at its slowest pace since 2009 weighed on shares in Asia, although Chinese shares staged a recovery after the securities regulator announced a series of measures to aid the market.
MSCI’s broadest index of Asia-Pacific shares outside Japan was up less than 0.l% after earlier falling as much as 0.9% ahead of the China GDP reading. Australian shares fell 0.05% and Japan’s Nikkei average ended 0.6% lower for its third straight week of declines.
Stocks in Europe managed a modest rise at the start of trading, but fell back into the red.
The MSCI All-Country World Index, which tracks shares in 47 countries, was down 0.2% on the day. It was set for a fourth weekly loss on the trot, which would make it its longest weekly losing streak since the end of 2015.
In currencies, the dollar index, a gauge of the greenback’s value against major peers, was 0.1% higher at 95.981. Meanwhile, the pound rose after EU negotiator Michel Barnier said a Brexit deal with the UK was 90% done although hurdles remained.
Oil prices ticked higher after falling on Thursday. US crude was up 0.1% at $68.68 a barrel and Brent crude was trading at $79.37 a barrel, also 0.1% higher.
Spot gold gained 0.1% to $1,226.14 an ounce.