Ethiopian crew’s voices may unlock high-stakes Boeing inquiry
Ethiopian investigators have the crew’s last dialogue as airlines make contingency plans with more than $500bn worth of orders on hold
Addis Ababa/Paris — On Tuesday, the investigation into the final minutes of Ethiopian Airlines flight 302 turned to the secrets in the cockpit voice recorder as Boeing and a shaken global aviation industry hung on the outcome.
The voices of captain Yared Getachew and first officer Ahmednur Mohammed could reveal what led to the March 10 crash of the Boeing 737 MAX that has worrying parallels with another disaster involving the same model off Indonesia in October.
The twin disasters killed 346 people.
Black box data was downloaded in France but only Ethiopian experts leading the probe have heard the dialogue between Getachew and Mohammed. The data was back in Addis Ababa on Tuesday, sources familiar with the probe told Reuters.
Experts believe a new automated system in Boeing’s flagship MAX fleet — intended to stop stalling by dipping the nose — may have played a role in both crashes, with pilots unable to override it as their jets plunged downwards.
Both came down just minutes after take-off after erratic flight patterns and loss of control reported by the pilots. However, every accident is a unique chain of human and technical factors, experts say.
The prestige of Ethiopian Airlines, one of Africa’s most successful companies, and Boeing, the world’s biggest aircraft maker and a massive US exporter, is at stake.
Awkward questions for industry
Law makers and safety experts are questioning how thoroughly regulators vetted the MAX model and how well pilots were trained on new features. For now, regulators have grounded the existing fleet of more than 300 MAX aircraft and deliveries of nearly 5,000 more — worth well over $500bn — are on hold.
Pressure on the Chicago-headquartered company has grown with news that federal prosecutors and the US department of transportation are scrutinising how carefully the MAX model was developed, two people briefed on the matter said.
In the hope of getting its MAX line back into the air soon, Boeing said it will roll out a software update and revise pilot training
The US justice department was looking at the Federal Aviation Administration’s (FAA) oversight of Boeing, one of the people said. And last week, a federal grand jury issued at least one subpoena to an entity involved in the plane’s development.
The EU is watching anxiously. Its aviation safety agency EASA promised its own deep look at Boeing’s software updates and failure modes.
“On our side, we will not allow the aircraft to fly if we have not found acceptable answers to all our questions,” its executive director Patrick Ky told an EU parliament committee hearing. “Whatever the FAA does. OK? This is a personal guarantee that I make in front of you.”
In the hope of getting its MAX line back into the air soon, Boeing said it will roll out a software update and revise pilot training. In the case of the Lion Air crash in Indonesia, it has raised questions about whether crew used the correct procedures.
The MAX, which offers cost savings of about 15% on fuel, was developed for service from 2017 after the successful launch by its main rival of the Airbus A320neo.
After Ethiopia, France and the US all noted parallels with the Indonesia crash, one person familiar with the probe said black box data showed the Ethiopian Airlines jet’s “angle of attack” was “very similar” to the Lion Air plane.
The angle of attack measures degrees between the air flow and the wing. If too high, it can cause an aerodynamic stall.
In the hot seat over its certification of the MAX without demanding additional training and its closeness to Boeing, the FAA has said it is “absolutely” confident in its vetting. But given the US probe, Canada said it would do its own independent certification.
The crisis has put airline companies in a spin. Norwegian Airlines has already said it will seek compensation after grounding its MAX aircraft. Various firms are reconsidering Boeing orders, and some are revising financial forecasts given that they now cannot count on maintenance and fuel savings factored in from the MAX.
Illustrating the hoops airlines were jumping through, Air Canada said it intends to keep its MAX aircraft grounded until at least July 1, will accelerate intake of recently acquired Airbus A321 planes, and has hired other carriers to provide extra capacity meantime.
Beyond the corporate ramifications, anguished relatives are still waiting to find out what happened.
Many have visited the crash site in a charred field to seek some closure, but there is anger at the slow pace of information and all they have been given for funerals is earth.