How Amazon’s battle with Reliance got stuck in a legal quagmire
Complex legal dispute stalls $3.4bn sale of assets
New Delhi — For more than a year, Amazon and India's Future Group have been locked in a complex legal stand-off that has stalled Future’s $3.4bn sale of assets to the US firm’s rival Reliance Industries — with no end in sight.
Here is what the dispute, seen as key to deciding who gets an upper hand in one of the world’s fastest-growing retail markets is all about.
What triggered the dispute?
In 2019, Amazon and Future, number two player in India behind market leader Reliance, became business partners when the US. company invested $200m in a gift voucher unit of the Indian group.
That deal, Amazon argues, came with non-compete clauses that prohibited Future from selling retail assets to certain rivals, including Reliance, run by one of India’s richest men, Mukesh Ambani. The deal also included clauses for settlement of any disputes under rules laid down by the Singapore International Arbitration Centre.
But in 2020, Future — hit hard by the Covid-19 pandemic — decided to sell assets to Reliance.
Amazon then approached Singapore arbitrators and successfully stopped the sale. Both parties have also challenged each other with lawsuits in Indian courts, including the supreme court, since the “seat of arbitration” remains in New Delhi and Indian law governs the proceedings.
What do Amazon and Future say?
Amazon argues various agreements signed in 2019 with Future gave it special rights over Future’s retail assets, some of which it had also hoped to ultimately own should India’s rules for foreign investors be eased. The potential Future-Reliance deal “destroys” the latter prospect, the US company has said.
Future denies any wrongdoing, saying Amazon is illegally seeking to exert control on Future’s retail business. Future Retail — the group’s flagship retail arm — says it faces liquidation and its more than 27,000 employees can become jobless if the Reliance deal fails.
What is the bigger picture?
At stake is whether Amazon can become a bigger force in a $900bn retail market, with 1.3-billion consumers, from Reliance.
Conglomerate Reliance has operations including 1,100 supermarkets, while Future has more than 1,500. Both are expanding fast into e-commerce, but the Future deal will boost the retail footprint of Reliance, which has attracted marquee foreign investors in the business.
For its part, Amazon has invested $6.5bn in India, which it counts as a key growth market where it is a leading e-commerce player. The Future partnership had already allowed Amazon to boost its online portfolio of grocery deliveries by integrating the Indian company’s stores on its website.
Keeping Future away from Reliance chimes with Amazon’s efforts to combat billionaire Ambani’s growth plans. In one confidential legal filing, Amazon said Reliance’s consolidated position with Future “will further restrict competition in the Indian retail market”.
How did India's antitrust agency get involved?
Future complained to India’s antitrust agency, the Competition Commission of India (CCI), that Amazon was making incorrect and contradictory submissions about the intent of the 2019 deal.
Amazon said it never concealed any information, but last December the CCI suspended its approval of the 2019 deal with Future, saying there was “a deliberate design on the part of Amazon to suppress the actual scope” of the deal and its interest in Future’s retail businesses.
While Amazon contends the CCI acted beyond its powers, Future maintains the US company no longer has any right to assert its claims as the 2019 deal itself now lacks regulatory approval.
In a setback for the US giant, the Delhi high court this month halted the Singapore arbitration proceedings between the two sides in light of the Indian antitrust decision. The arbitration has since been on hold, but Amazon has appealed against the decisions in Indian courts which are yet to hear the matter.
Would you like to comment on this article or view other readers' comments?
Register (it’s quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.