Platinum pay deal would boost Ramaphosa’s investment plan
But labour unions are expected to go on strike, which could send platinum prices soaring
When the world’s biggest platinum miners sit down with labour unions in May to negotiate a three-year wage deal, it could prove an early test of Cyril Ramaphosa’s new presidency.
An amicable outcome would bolster Ramaphosa – the former mine union leader and one-time platinum company investor – as he seeks to lure foreign investors. However, both sides are tense and it is feared that unions will strike, which could send platinum prices soaring.
“Ramaphosa’s key priority is to send a positive signal on reforming the economy, but there will be high levels of instability after the election,” said Andre Duvenhage, professor of politics at North West University. “The platinum belt is probably the most volatile environment in SA.”
Khusela Diko, a spokesperson for Ramaphosa, declined to comment.
The industry is bracing for a tough round of talks. The Association of Mineworkers and Construction Union (Amcu), the largest and most militant labour organisation in the sector, is expected to push for higher wages as the industry reaps windfall profits. Across the negotiating table, some producers have accumulated cash to withstand a repeat of the prolonged and violent strike in 2014.
A strike on a similar scale could cut platinum output by as much as 40,000 to 45,000 ounces per week, according to Johnson Matthey, a key maker of catalytic converters for the auto industry. The company is predicting a platinum market deficit this year, even assuming no widespread strikes.
Preliminary wage talks should start this month, according to Johan Theron, a spokesman for Impala Platinum Holdings. The negotiations will pit Amcu and three other labor unions against at least seven producers, including Anglo American Platinum and Sibanye.
Optimists can point to the relatively smooth negotiations during the last wage round three years ago, when Anglo American’s platinum unit was first to agree a deal with Amcu. The union accepted an increase of 12.5% for the lowest paid workers, after initially demanding a 47% increment.
However, some fear Amcu is gearing up for industrial action after SA’s regulator threatened to deregister the union for failing to hold a regular congress and leadership elections. That could potentially impair the union’s ability to negotiate with mining companies and collect dues from its members.
“The likelihood is that workers may be upset and go on a strike again,” said retired Anglican Bishop Johannes Seoka, who played a key role in mediating an end to the 2014 dispute. “That will impact negatively on mining, which is already struggling. Workers will lose.”
Deregistering Amcu could have far-ranging repercussions, said Crispen Chinguno, a senior lecturer in sociology at Sol Plaatje University in the Northern Cape province. “It may push Amcu to adopt a more combative strategy in its struggle for survival,” he said.
Amcu leader Joseph Mathunjwa, who has long been critical of the governing ANC, said there is a political agenda behind moves to deregister the union. When asked in April, he declined to say who he thought was behind the move, but asked: “Who are the richest black people in South Africa?”
Platinum-group metals are one of SA’s biggest exports, but less than a year ago producers were closing shafts and cutting thousands of jobs as a stronger rand combined with stagnating metal prices to squeeze profit margins. Another platinum strike would hurt both the industry and the unions, according to Peter Major, a mining analyst at Mergence Corporate Solutions.
“There is no more commodities boom, and no money for mining investments in South Africa,” he said. “This country’s economy is on its knees and mines are really shedding jobs.”
Some producers are yet to recover from the 2014 strike, which cost about $2bn in revenue. More than half of the nation’s production of platinum group metals is either marginal or unprofitable, according to the Minerals Council SA, a lobby group that includes most of the mining companies operating in the country.
As platinum-industry investors gather in London this week, they will be casting a wary eye toward SA. Miners’ earnings have rebounded on a weaker rand and rally in palladium and rhodium prices, but some producers seem in little mood to compromise.
“Don’t try to force our hand with a threat of a strike, because quite honestly we will take a strike,” Sibanye CEO Neal Froneman said in an interview in Johannesburg. “We are not intimidated by those types of things.”