BNP Paribas under scrutiny for use of middleman in Deutsche deal
The probe highlights the red flags raised when banks pay outsiders to open doors or cultivate counterparties
Paris — BNP Paribas’s deal for Deutsche Bank’s business catering to hedge funds, a landmark agreement aimed at vaulting the lender into the Wall Street elite, is being scrutinised by French regulators over a fee to a middleman.
The bank paid hundreds of thousands of pounds to former Goldman Sachs banker Simon Lloyd months after the transaction was completed in September 2019, according to people familiar with the matter. The French anti-corruption agency, known as AFA, identified the incident during a routine audit and is due to issue a report in the next few weeks.
Britain’s Financial Conduct Authority has also received complaints about the payment, the people said, though it is not clear if it will open a formal inquiry.
The probe highlights the red flags raised when banks pay outsiders to open doors or cultivate counterparties. Societe Generale, for example, paid more than $1bn in 2018 to resolve US allegations it paid bribes to secure deals with Libya.
In 2019, Deutsche Bank settled a suit — without admitting liability — from a Dutch housing firm stemming from payments to a middleman who arranged their derivatives trades.
BNP Paribas, Deutsche Bank, AFA and the FCA declined to comment. Lloyd, who is not personally the focus of the inquiry and has not been accused of any wrongdoing, did not respond to messages sent to his LinkedIn profile or to phone messages left at his office.
Shares in BNP Paribas slid 5.4% to about €39 in Paris, leading the falls in European bank stocks.
Deutsche Bank’s 2019 decision to exit the business serving hedge funds, known as prime brokerage, was part of CEO Christian Sewing’s retreat from equities. BNP Paribas and Citigroup emerged as potential buyers.
BNP Paribas CEO Jean-Laurent Bonnafe was counting on it to vault the French lender into the top tier of the global industry, which is dominated by Wall Street giants including Morgan Stanley, JPMorgan and Goldman Sachs.
Enter Lloyd, an Australian who founded a two-person advisory shop in London called Barbon Advisors after working at Goldman Sachs for a decade through 2011.
Early in the process, Lloyd gave a leads to a BNP Paribas executive that Deutsche Bank was looking to sell, according to one person familiar with the transaction. Some officials at the French bank later became concerned over the possible appearance of impropriety, the person said.
Meanwhile, executives at Deutsche Bank were surprised to receive a phone call from Lloyd flagging the French bank’s interest and wondered why their counterparts at BNP Paribas had not just made contact directly, another person said.
The Lloyd payment came to the attention of BNP Paribas officials in early 2020 after it was initially sent for approval via the procurement department, which typically deals with suppliers. An internal committee looked into it and the finders fee was eventually paid in the first half of 2020, more than six months after the deal was announced and the unit’s 1,000 employees began to move to the French bank from the German one.
BNP Paribas has called the deal a success. The French bank says it is on course to become the biggest prime broker in Europe and aims to eventually be one of the four largest on the planet, with client balances reaching between $250bn to $300bn, Bloomberg reported at the time of the deal.
In the quarter that ended September 30, the BNP Paribas unit that includes prime brokerage reported revenue rose 21% to €466m, beating the highest estimate.
Would you like to comment on this article or view other readers' comments?
Register (it’s quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.