Insurers bracing as UK hospitality groups head to courts over lockdown losses
Struggling British pubs, restaurants and bakery chains head to court over Covid-19 business interruption payouts
London — Some of the world’s biggest insurers are bracing as a second wave of multi-million pound lawsuits, brought by struggling British pubs, restaurants and bakery chains over lockdown losses, starts hitting London’s courts next week.
Zurich, MS Amlin, Liberty Mutual, Allianz and AXA are among those due in court one year after Britain’s Supreme Court ruled that many insurers had been wrong to deny thousands of companies, battered by the Covid-19 pandemic, business interruption payouts.
Insurers have since paid out £1.3bn ($1.8bn), according to the Financial Conduct Authority. But the ruling did not cover all policy wordings and, where it deemed claims valid, some companies are now disputing payout levels.
Companies and insurers have been at loggerheads over whether business interruption policies provide cover for Covid-19-related losses since government lockdowns in March 2020 shuttered shops, bars and restaurants.
Corbin & King, the owner of London’s Wolseley and Delaunay restaurants, starts off with a high court trial on Monday that has been accelerated through the courts because of its interest to other policyholders.
It is suing AXA for about £4.5m in a dispute that hinges in part on the scope of “denial of access” cover, designed to protect insured venues that are shut by public authorities on health grounds.
AXA declined to comment. Corbin & King did not respond to a request for comment.
Other businesses have potentially tens of millions of pounds riding on the outcome of the case, said Mark Pring, partner at law firm Reed Smith.
“We have clients sitting there who are very interested because their wordings are either materially similar or overlap,” he said.
Three other companies are also taking on their insurers in closely-watched disputes that focus in part on the aggregation of losses: whether policies have been triggered multiple times during the pandemic and qualify for multiple payments.
The Slug and Lettuce owner Stonegate, Britain’s largest pub group, is bringing an £845m claim against Zurich, MS Amlin and Liberty Mutual, who insured 760 of its 4,500 venues.
A trial, which will also examine whether government support payments can be deducted from claims, is scheduled for June.
The three insurers allege their liability is limited to £17.5m, of which £14.5m has been paid, according to court documents. They declined to comment on Friday.
Multi-million pound claims have also been filed by sandwich-to-pasty chain Greggs against Zurich and by Strada and Coppa Club owner Various Eateries against Allianz.
Various Eateries and Allianz said in a joint statement they were seeking a ruling on “a number of issues” left unresolved by the Supreme Court. Greggs declined to comment.
Would you like to comment on this article or view other readers' comments?
Register (it’s quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.