Move by black investors could affect Rio Tinto’s BEE status
Black investors are frustrated by the suspension of dividends, partly due to disruptions caused by the Covid-19 pandemic, and community opposition that stymied expansion plans
Rio Tinto’s operation in SA is facing the loss of a large bloc of Black investors, a move that would leave it below the legal minimum for black ownership, two people familiar with the situation said.
The main investors in Blue Horison Investments, which holds 24% of Rio-controlled titanium producer Richards Bay Minerals, have told Rio they want to be permitted to to sell a stake they value at R5.5bn or have it bought out by RBM, the people said.
The black investors are frustrated by the suspension of dividends, partly due to disruptions caused by the coronavirus pandemic, and community opposition that stymied expansion plans. By law, mining assets in the country, at the time when the deal was concluded, must be at least 26% black-owned. RBM is also 2% owned by black employees.
“It remains the company’s desire to have a strong and supportive shareholder base for RBM and a structure that ensures ongoing compliance with applicable BEE legislation,” Rio said in a response to queries, declining to comment further on the dispute.
Should the Black shareholders get their wish RBM could need to find new partners to comply with the law. Not complying with the law would jeopardise its right to operate.
Blue Horison, which is 55% held by black investment companies and 45% owned by communities that live near the operation, which produces minerals used in paint and plastic, is locked into the holding until 2022 under the terms of a $550m refinancing that was concluded in 2015. After that they are permitted to sell the shares but other RBM shareholders have a pre-emptive right to buy the shares should they choose to do so.
One of the investment companies lodged a complaint with a unit of the department of trade, industry and competition that arbitrates in disputes over BEE holdings after they received no response, the people said.
An acknowledgment of receipt of the complaint made to the Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment Commission on April 8 said the body may take as long as a year to make a finding, the document seen by Bloomberg shows.
RBM is one of the world’s biggest so-called mineral sands operations. Rio doubled its stake in the operation in 2012 by buying BHP’s 37% stake for $1.7bn.
While RBM has been paying off debt in increments of about $29m every six months, it is due to make a balloon payment of $223m in November 2022, documents seen by Bloomberg show. That is raising concern that there will be a further sthat would lock the black shareholders into the holding until 2030, the people said.
“A strong operational performance with minimal disruptions is required to meet the capital and loan repayments,” Bradley Reddy, then RBM’s CFO, said in a document sent to shareholders on January 14 and seen by Bloomberg. “The projected capital and loan repayments is likely to exceed $700m over the next two years.”
Rio Tinto and RBM aim to maintain a balance between cash returns to shareholders and investment in the business, Rio said in its response to Bloomberg’s queries.
The black investors, while agreeing to the 2015 refinancing, have since become disenchanted by recurrent community protests that have led to the periodic shutting of the operation and halted the planned $463m Zulti South expansion, the people said.
Late in 2020, RBM’s earning fell $180m short of projections, a shareholder document seen by Bloomberg shows.
Bloomberg News. For more articles like this, please visit us at bloomberg.com
Would you like to comment on this article or view other readers' comments?
Register (it’s quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.