Toshiba CEO Nobuaki Kurumatani attends a news conference at the company's headquarters in Tokyo, Japan, May 15 2018. Picture: REUTERS/ISSEI KATO
Toshiba CEO Nobuaki Kurumatani attends a news conference at the company's headquarters in Tokyo, Japan, May 15 2018. Picture: REUTERS/ISSEI KATO

Tokyo —  Toshiba CEO Nobuaki Kurumatani resigned on Wednesday amid controversy over a $20bn buyout bid from CVC Capital Partners, while its shares rose on reports that KKR and Brookfield are also planning offers.

Satoshi Tsunakawa, who led the company before Kurumatani and until Wednesday was chair, will once again assume the helm.

Kurumatani, CEO for three years, had been under fire over the bid from CVC, his former employer, as well as facing allegations that investors were pressured before a shareholder meeting to support desired board nominations.

CVC's offer to take the Japanese conglomerate private and retain incumbent management was perceived by some in the company as designed to shield Kurumatani from activist shareholders, Toshiba sources have said.

Those shareholders have successfully pushed for an independent investigation into the allegations, sources familiar with the matter have said.

CVC was planning to team up with US firm Bain Capital for its buyout offer, the Nikkei newspaper reported after Kurumatani's resignation. A representative for Bain declined to comment. CVC also declined to comment.

CVC's proposal had sparked a strong backlash from Toshiba managers, prompting them to lobby against it to the government, said one of the sources, who declined to be identified due to the sensitivity of the matter.

“Tsunakawa has the trust of various stakeholders,” Toshiba board chair Osamu Nagayama told a news conference.

Toshiba said Kurumatani was stepping down to “recharge” after achieving his plan to revive the conglomerate after an accounting scandal. Reuters was not immediately able to reach him for comment.

People familiar with matter said two board members had told Kurumatani they planned to oust him due to his slumping support among shareholders and staff, and that the CVC offer had only accelerated the move.

Nagayama said CVC's April 6 proposal was unsolicited, lacked substance and required cautious consideration. He noted that a law which restricts foreign ownership in Japanese companies with important technology would have to be taken into account.

Toshiba would consider setting up an independent committee of external directors after receiving a formal proposal from CVC, he added.

Tsunakawa, who has a reputation for being on better terms with Toshiba's large activist shareholder base, said the company needed to rebuild trust with investors and acknowledged there was room to improve governance.

The Toshiba shareholder vote in March for an independent probe was a watershed victory for corporate governance in Japan, marking the first time that a motion by an activist shareholder has won approval at a major company.

Both Nagayama and Tsunakawa suggested current management did not intend to be in place for too long.

“I am aiming to complete my mission quickly and hand over to the next generation,” Tsunakawa said.

Shares in Toshiba closed 6% higher at ¥4,860, compares with the ¥5,000 level that a source has said was proposed by CVC.

Other suitors may be waiting in the wings.

Private equity firm KKR is considering a buyout offer that would exceed CVC's, the Financial Times has reported, citing several people briefed on the plans.

Canada's Brookfield Asset Management is in the preliminarily stages of exploring an offer, Bloomberg News reported, citing a person with knowledge of the matter.

A representative for KKR Japan declined to comment. Brookfield did not immediately respond to a request to comment.

Battered by accounting scandals, huge writedowns for its US nuclear business, as well as the sale of its semiconductor unit, the once-storied conglomerate is a shadow of its former self.

That said, it remains one of Japan's few manufacturers of nuclear power reactors and makes defence equipment including lithium-ion batteries for submarines, meaning any sale of Toshiba would need government approval.

Toshiba also retains a 40% stake in Kioxia Holdings, its former chip unit which is controlled by Bain.

It has promised to return to shareholders a majority of gains made from reducing its stake in a planned Kioxia IPO and to gradually unwind the holding after Kioxia is listed.

Kioxia's fortunes have risen amid a global shortage of semiconductors and as consumers spend much more time at home due to the coronavirus pandemic, boosting demand for premium electronic devices as well as more data centres.

Tsunakawa said there was no change in Toshiba's plans to support the Kioxia IPO.

Micron Technology and Western Digital are individually exploring a potential deal for Kioxia that could value the firm at about $30bn, the Wall Street Journal reported in March.

At the time, Micron declined to comment, while Western Digital and Kioxia did not respond to Reuters's requests for comment.

Reuters  

Would you like to comment on this article or view other readers' comments?
Register (it’s quick and free) or sign in now.

Speech Bubbles

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.