Dueling billionaires: Who will blink first, Bezos or Ambani, for Indian retail control?
Accusations of insider trading and contractual breaches, nationalistic cries to keep the US giant at bay — what started as a spat has become a war and the battleground is the grocery business
Mumbai/New Delhi — Jeff Bezos and Mukesh Ambani, two of the world’s richest men, face a turning point in a battle for pre-eminence in India’s booming, nearly trillion-dollar retail market.
The outcome of a legal dispute that has embroiled the billionaires’ Amazon and Reliance Industries empires, respectively — where a court ruling is imminent — may shape India’s retail landscape for years to come.
The winner in the fight for Future Retail, Amazon’s estranged local partner, will get pole position in the race to meet the daily needs of more than a billion people.
Accusations of insider trading and contractual breaches, as well as nationalistic cries to keep the US giant at bay, mark the high-stakes fight, which has snowballed from what began as a dispute between Amazon and Future.
If Amazon succeeds, it may slow Reliance’s plans to expand its e-commerce and bricks-and-mortar operations. If Amazon loses, its hopes of expanding its interests in India’s second-largest retailer and cashing in on its key grocery supply chain will be dashed, industry insiders say.
Amazon is trying to stop Reliance’s $3.4bn purchase of Future Group’s retail assets. The US company, which won an injunction from an arbitrator to block the Reliance-Future deal, accuses its partner of breaching some pre-existing agreements, misleading the public and insider trading. Future denies the allegations.
Amazon, Reliance and Future did not respond to requests for comment.
Bezos’s behemoth is a formidable foe, but Ambani has a history as a disrupter. He has shaken foreign telecom firms by offering dirt-cheap data. Industry executives see his e-commerce plans as a threat for Amazon and Walmart’s Flipkart.
“If Reliance moves faster and faster, obviously it’ll become very difficult for anyone else to gain,” said Himanshu Bajaj, head of consulting firm Kearney’s India retail practice.
Reliance, seeking to expand its JioMart e-commerce business, this month completed a $6.4bn fundraising by selling a stake in its retail arm to such investors as Silver Lake Partners and KKR.
Groceries, ‘Big Brother’ in America
India’s retail market will grow 46% over the next four years to an annual $1.3-trillion, reckons Forrester Research. The key battle is over groceries, expected to be worth about $740bn a year by 2024.
Founded by Kishore Biyani, dubbed India’s retail king, Future has transformed the country’s retailing in recent decades, before Covid-19 hit the business so hard this year that Biyani was forced to find a new buyer.
About 1,300 of Future’s more than 1,700 retail outlets in 400 cities sell groceries. Its budget supermarkets cater to middle-class shoppers, while its upmarket stores offer products such as imported cheese and fresh guacamole, relatively rare in India’s retail landscape.
That makes Future a prized asset for both Reliance and Amazon.
Reliance and Future dominate the market, with the next competitor, Avenue Supermarts’s DMart, having just 220 outlets in about 70 cities.
While Reliance boasts around 11,000 retail stores, just 800 of those offer food and groceries, UBS estimates. Future’s retail assets would nearly triple Reliance’s footprint in the grocery segment and boost its e-commerce plans, said Forrester analyst Satish Meena.
Amazon sees Future as a long-term play to optimise its supply chain for grocery delivery, an area where it has lagged, Meena said. “Grocery is the category in which you fight,” he said, while losing Future to Reliance would “slow Amazon”.
This month, Amazon, Future and Reliance hired some of India’s top lawyers, who argued at length before a New Delhi judge. She is expected to decide soon whether to restrain Amazon from approaching regulators to block the Future-Reliance deal.
Amid heated legal arguments and patriotic appeals, Future’s lawyer attacked Amazon as “Big Brother” in America, arguing Future faces bankruptcy if the Reliance deal fails.
The lawyer urged the judge, “Please don’t allow this American giant to kill Future.”
Would you like to comment on this article or view other readers' comments?
Register (it’s quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.