US lawmakers say Boeing CEO guilty of ‘concealment and opaqueness’
Boeing, however, fully supports CEO Dennis Muilenburg, sayings he did everything right during the 737 MAX grounding
New York — On Tuesday, Boeing’s new chair gave a forceful vote of confidence in CEO Dennis Muilenburg amid calls in the US Congress for the embattled Boeing CEO to resign after two deadly crashes.
“Dennis has done everything right,” Boeing chair David Calhoun told CNBC, praising Muilenburg for keeping the board closely abreast of efforts to return the 737 MAX back to service after 346 people were killed in the accidents. “To date, he has our confidence.”
Calhoun acknowledged that some of Boeing’s assumptions in the development of the MAX were faulty, but hit back at suggestions that the company cut corners and compromised safety.
Boeing’s board has kept a low profile during the crisis over the MAX, which was grounded worldwide in March following the second of the two crashes.
On October 11, the company stripped Muilenburg of the chair title — replacing him with Calhoun — even as he was kept on as CEO and as a member of the board. Last week, Muilenburg endured two days of bruising grilling and criticism from law makers probing the issues that led to the two accidents of the top-selling jet.
Boeing has acknowledged problems with the manoeuvring characteristics augmentation system (MCAS), an automated flight control system implicated in both the Lion Air and Ethiopian Airlines crashes.
Calhoun said the crashes also revealed “flawed” assumptions about how pilots would react to a malfunction of the system.
“No-one was hiding anything, it was a set of engineering decisions that ended up being wrong,” Calhoun said. “And our job now is to make sure that whatever processes we had, whatever process our regulator has, that those processes never allow for this to ever happen again.”
But lawmakers have depicted the crashes as evidence Boeing had cut corners on safety to rush the MAX into service to compete with a plane from rival Airbus.
US representative Peter DeFazio, an Oregon Democrat who chaired last week’s hearing by the House transportation committee, pointed to documents showing Boeing leadership during the MAX’s development was “aware of many of the problems that engineers are now attempting to fix”.
DeFazio faulted Muilenburg’s responses to many questions as “consistent with a culture of concealment and opaqueness”.
“The bottom line is that there are a lot of unanswered questions, and our investigation has a long way to go to get the answers everyone deserves, especially the families of the crash victims,” DeFazio said in a letter to congressional colleagues.
However, Calhoun said criticism of Boeing’s corporate culture missed the mark. While Boeing could take steps to strengthen the visibility of its commitment to safety, “I do not believe that this instance is indicative of a cultural problem,” he said.
Meanwhile, he said Muilenburg is completely focused on returning the MAX to service and succeeding in the face of “one of the most difficult situations any CEO that I’ve ever known has lived through. We’re going to support Dennis”.
Calhoun said Muilenburg had asked not to receive a bonus for 2019 after law makers lambasted the CEO over his pay at the hearing last week. In 2018, Muilenburg’s total compensation package was $23.4m, according to a securities filing.
Calhoun also said the company is not considering clawing back Muilenburg’s pay from earlier years because there was “no culpability”.